Saturday, February 13, 2016

Bible Commentary - 1 Chronicles 6

In this chapter, we are given a genealogy of the tribe of Levi, their assignment to roles in the temple, and the distribution of the Levitical towns throughout Israel.

This is quite a long chapter (81 verses) and it is also quite diverse in the topics it covers, which makes it a bit hard to find a unifying theme. As far as I can tell, this chapter is meant to give a broad overview of the Levitical tribe in every way that the Chronicler cares about them. It begins by listing all of the high priests from Levi down to Jehozadak and the Babylonian exile (which incidentally shows that Chronicles must have been written some time after the exile). Then it lists the clans of Levi (a traditional genealogy), and then it lists the genealogies of several temple musicians appointed by David, and then it concludes with the Levitical towns in Israel. The emphasis on the priesthood and temple musicians is relevant to the later narrative sections in Chronicles. The author of Chronicles shows a deep interest in everything related to the temple. It’s not clear to me why the author is interested in the Levitical towns.

In general, the length of this section is evidence of the author’s preoccupation with Levi compared to the other tribes like Reuben, Gad or Manasseh. All put together, those 2.5 tribes were describe in 26 verses, less than 1/3rd of the length of the passage for Levi alone. I think this preoccupation is driven by two factors: the first, as I said, is that the author is trying to glorify and honor the temple-building operation by David and Solomon, and the second is to implicitly legitimize the religious institutions in his own time. There are several tribes in the post-exilic period that maintain a lot of significance and power, and all of these tribes receive extended treatment in the genealogy. Foremost amongst them are Judah and Levi, with somewhat lesser coverage for Benjamin and I’d also say Simeon.

Those are my general thoughts. Now let’s dig into some details.

One of the first thing I noticed in v. 1-3 is that according to this genealogy Moses is just three generations removed from Levi. It is exceedingly unlikely that 430 years (Ex 12:40) could have passed in three generations, which indicates that genealogical telescoping is likely occurring here. That is, I think the Chronicler is possibly omitting people from the genealogical record for the sake of poetic symbolism or (more likely) because his original sources also omit certain people between Levi and Moses from the genealogical records.

Next, when listing the high priests in v. 3-15, Nadab, Abihu and Ithamar are all mentioned as sons of Aaron, but Nadab and Abihu died when they rebelled against Moses so even though they were both older than Eleazar, they never served as high priest and their families were also wiped out.  Strangely, there are known high priests from Samuel and Kings, who are recorded by name in those books, but are omitted from this listing of high priests.  For instance, Jehoiada (2 Kings 12:2), Uriah (2 Kings 16:10), Eli (1 Samuel 1:9) and Abiathar (2 Samuel 8:17) are all omitted.  It's possible that Eli and Abiathar are left out because they weren't part of the priestly line  that continued through Zadok, but I don't know why Jehoiada and Uriah are left out.  The author of Chronicles demonstrates clear knowledge of Samuel and Kings, so these omissions cannot possibly be by accident or ignorance.  It's definitely intentional, perhaps for brevity or perhaps because he's trying to emphasize the priestly line of Zadok vs. the other priestly lines (like Abiathar).  Verses 50-53 gives the same priestly line from Aaron to Ahimaaz, because this is the line that is permitted to offer sacrifices in the most holy place (v. 49).  It's pretty clear from here and elsewhere (especially 1 Kings 1-2) that there was a power struggle between Zadok and Abiathar, and the Chronicler emphatically sides with Zadok.

This section of the genealogy is (as I described it elsewhere) vertical, but then in v. 16 it becomes a horizontal genealogy, expanding outwards to describe the clans of Levi across the three main groupings: Gershon, Kohath and Merari. The vertical genealogy indicates the author's interest in the high priestly line, and the transition back to a horizontal genealogy permits the author to broaden the context in preparation for his next topical focus.

The reference to Amminadab is interesting because in most cases, the name Amminadab is usually affiliated with Judah (Num 1:7).  In fact, this is the only place in the bible where Amminadab is called a son of Kohath.  Usual listings (e.g. Ex 6:18) and even later in this same chapter place Izhar as a son of Kohath instead of Amminadab.  It's possible that Amminadab is called a son of Kohath because Amminadab's daughter married Aaron (Ex 6:23), and more to the point, the Chronicler may wish to associate Judah and Levi together to justify David's interference with temple affairs as well as the temple's placement in Judah.

I also think it's noteworthy that Samuel is called a descendant of Kohath.  This is actually contrary to 1 Samuel 1:1 that specifically calls Elkanah (the father of Samuel) an Ephraimite.  It's interesting because I remember one of the most confusing parts of the book of Samuel is why Samuel, an Ephraimite, would be permitted to minister in the temple and to remain in the tabernacle before the mercy seat (1 Sam 3:3).  It would actually explain a lot if Samuel were really a Levite.  I'm just skeptical because this is the first time it's ever implied that Samuel was a Levite and the book of Samuel is much closer to a primary source than Chronicles.  Chronicles shows that it's willing to bend the truth to make certain political or theological points, and it may be doing that here also.  However, many sections of Chronicles shows that the author of Chronicles had access to a lot of what are now missing works, so I don't think it's impossible that the Chronicler is deriving this section of the genealogy from a historical source that no longer exists, which could also explain the deviation from 1 Samuel.

The Chronicler is especially focused on Samuel because verses 22-28 and 33-38 form a chiasm centered around Samuel and his son Joel.  Verses 22-28 give a genealogical descent from Kohath to Samuel, and verses 33-38 give a reverse genealogy from Samuel back up to Kohath.  Samuel is very important in the kingship narrative because he's the man who anoints both Saul and David.  The Chronicler begins his historical narrative in chapter 10 with Saul and David, so it's appropriate that the genealogy would emphasize the men related to those stories.  The genealogy in verse 33 also associates Heman (an important musician) with Samuel (an important priest and prophet).  It's a subtle point, but I think it says a lot about the Chronicler's intentions with this book: he wants to tie together the legendary heroes of Israel's past with the "modern" (in his time) worship and temple ministry.

Verse 31 (in the middle of this chiasm) also transitions the genealogy to the next major section, the musicians.  Besides Heman's association with Samuel, this section just as importantly declares that the musicians are appointed by David (v. 31).  There are three chief musicians, one from each clan of Levi, and we are given their genealogies as well.  Heman (from Kohath) is the chief musician, perhaps because Kohath is also the clan of Moses and Aaron and the high priests.  This at least partially establishes the equality of the Levitical clans, since they each have a representative, though Heman from Kohath is given the preeminence.

Lastly, this chapter concludes by listing the Levitical towns (which they received in lieu of a tribal inheritance), which is largely copied from Joshua 21.  I'm not sure why this is mentioned here, except perhaps to remind the readers that while the other tribes received land, the tribe of Levi received their temple ministry as their inheritance.  This could again be a subtle way of implying that the Levites are the only proper men to offer sacrifices and serve in the temple.  I also want to mention that there are four groups of towns, the first going to the sons of Aaron and then the three clans of Levi.  Even though Kohath is not the oldest son of Levi, he effectively gets a double portion of the Levitical towns because of the prominence of Aaron and the priestly line.  Other than that, I don't think there is anything notable or interesting in the list of towns.

Wednesday, February 3, 2016

Bible Commentary - 1 Chronicles 5

In this chapter, we read the genealogy for the two and a half tribes east of the Jordan.

Reuben, Gad and half of the tribe of Manasseh settled east of the Jordan in the conquered lands of Bashan and the Amorites.  We first read about this story in Numbers 32.  The author of Chronicles groups these three tribes together and gives their genealogical records grouped together, which makes sense when you consider the historical connection between them.  Sadly, these three tribes were most likely destroyed in the Assyrian invasion which was a couple hundred years before Chronicles was written, so this genealogy is more of a memorial to these tribes than anything else, and v. 25-26 refers to the events surrounding their exile.

Verses 1-2 explain why Judah was listed first in the genealogy: not because he had the right of the firstborn (which was given to Joseph) but because "a ruler came from him", referring to David.  When Reuben "defiled his father's marriage bed" back in Genesis 35:22, Jacob took away his right as the firstborn (Gen 49:3-4) and that's why these hundreds of years later Reuben is not given a place of honor in the genealogical record.

In verses 4-6, the genealogy becomes linear again, listing the father-to-son descent from Reuben down to Beerah, who was a tribal leader over Reuben in the time that they were destroyed.  When the Reubenites were exiled into Assyria, the genealogical records also ceased, which ominously marks the end of the northern tribes as a distinct people.

These tribes originally went to the Transjordan region because they had large flocks and these lands were large and well-suited for semi-nomadic shepherding.  It appears that they fought wars to expand their territory during the time of Saul when Israel was more successful and entering their golden age.  The Hagrites (possibly related to Hagar, a.k.a. Ishmaelites, i.e. Arabs) are a nomadic people who were probably also pastoralists with large flocks and entered into conflict with the Transjordan tribes because they wanted the same resources and land.  During later times, the Transjordan tribes gradually declined until they were destroyed by the Assyrians.

By the time this genealogy was written, the victories were distant memories, and even the Assyrian exile was fading into the past.  However, all of these stories are written with a sense of immediacy because much of it is copied from historical records, like v. 17 which indicates that the genealogy of Gad (and possibly also Reuben and Manasseh) was recorded during the reign of Jotham.

I think if there are two themes that I want to draw out of this chapter, they are as follows:

1) The historical connection between the genealogy and previous stories from the Pentateuch;
2) Obedience to God and the Law dictates the fate of the nation.  As they follow God, they are victorious, and as they turn from God they are defeated.

In light of everything I've written above, I think the connection is very clear between this genealogy and Israel's history.  Not only does this genealogy reference events from Genesis and Kings, but even the layout of this chapter is derived from the book of Numbers.

The second point is just as obvious.  Both the Gadites and the Manassites were valiant warriors and powerful, but God gives them victory or defeat based on their faith or lack thereof.  In verse 20, the Transjordan tribes are given victory because they "cried out" in prayer and God answered them, but later in v. 25 the Manassites are "unfaithful to the God of their fathers" so God stirred up the Assyrians to come and destroy them.  What I think is most interesting about this theme is how strongly it resonates with the book of Deuteronomy, where Deut 28 links the nation's obedience or lack thereof to God's covenant to all kinds of material blessings or curses respectively.  I think we find this kind of pattern in the book of Kings as well (where good kings are blessed when they draw the nation back to God and evil kings suffer in their idolatry), but this pattern in general represents a very specific kind of theology where material circumstances (i.e. wealth, famines, victory or defeat in wars) are directly responsive to the people's faithfulness towards God.  By identifying similarities in this kind of theology, we can see that the author of Chronicles not only knew the stories from the Pentateuch, but he also understood the ideas of the Pentateuch, in particular Deuteronomy.

We can juxtapose this kind of thinking with the book of Job (which we have not yet read) where Job suffers or is blessed regardless of how he responds to God.  In a similar vein, we could study the life of Joseph son of Jacob as being non-responsive to his faithfulness towards God.  He was faithful to God, got sold as a slave by his brothers, rose up in power, was thrown in prison again, and then rose up again.  His story is very dynamic and it involves numerous rises and falls from power completely independent of his faithfulness towards God (which we can reasonably assume was consistent).  Joseph's life is not the kind of life that easily fits into the Deut 28 pattern where blessings and curses are the result of your obedience to God's covenant.  David is another figure (principally described in the book of Samuel) who has many rises and falls from power that is (mostly) independent from his faithfulness towards God.

That said, I do think there Joseph's life fits into the Deut 28 pattern if you reinterpret the idea of "curses" in the context of Joseph's life.  Joseph was never cursed by God.  Though he suffered many setbacks, we can see that God actually blessed him with favor and success in nearly every situation he entered.  This is a much more nuanced concept than what you get in Deut 28, but I think it is more correct.  This chapter in Chronicles appears to promote the simpler notion that when the tribes sought God they were victorious, and when they sought idols they were defeated.  Not to say that the Chronicler is lying to us, but I think it's interesting how he presents these ideas in a way that very much agrees with Deuteronomy vs. the lives of Joseph and David.

For instance, the book of Chronicles leaves out many of the most difficult parts of David's life.  It never describes his years fleeing from Saul in the southern desert or the various revolts against him (several of which are directed by his own sons).  While there are multiple ways to interpret the book of Chronicles, I think it's possible that the Chronicler is viewing David's life through a Deut 28 lens, and sees it as inappropriate to describe David being "cursed" with hardships if he is faithful towards God, and hence tries to portray him as successful and exultant in everything he does.  Of course, we haven't gotten to that part of the story yet, but I would like my readers to be thinking about this theology (of blessings and curses) while they read Chronicles, since I think it is emblematic of the Chronicler's view on David's life in particular and Israel's history in general, up until their descent into the Babylonian exile.

Saturday, January 23, 2016

Bible Commentary - 1 Chronicles 4

In this chapter, the genealogy of Judah is concluded and we also read the genealogy of Simeon.

My commentary for this chapter is mostly minor notes, I don't see any big or important structural issues here.

After the previous chapter went deep into the family of David, listing descendants all the way down to the return from the Babylonian exile, this chapter jumps all the way back up to the sons of Judah.  Even though all of these people fall under the general category of "sons of Judah", there is a sudden and sharp temporal transition between the "sons of Elioenai" who would have lived c. 500 BCE and Perez son of Judah who would have lived c. 1500 BCE.  This is because the genealogy is shifting back from a "vertical" genealogy to a "horizontal" genealogy; since the author is done exploring the family tree of David, we now go back to the broad clans and families of Israel.

Verse 4 concludes the genealogy of Hur, which was interrupted by the family tree of David.

Verses 9-10 contain the prayer of Jabez, which is a very obscure passage but somehow became the title of a famous devotional book.  Since this is a moderately famous passage (at least, famous to some people) I feel like I should have something to say about it, but there isn't much that comes to mind.  Jabez as a biblical figure is only ever mentioned here and he does nothing.  The only thing I can think to say about Jabez is that he overcomes his name, where he was called pain and was born in pain, but God freed him from it.

It's hard to date some of the people in this genealogy.  Othniel is one of the first judges, but Caleb son of Jephunneh is a contemporary of Moses who would have died long before Othniel was born.  Even though this part of the genealogy is mostly horizontal, not all of these people lived together.

Mered is an obscure figure who is not mentioned anywhere else in the bible, but he marries one of the daughters of Pharaoh.  It's possible that Mered was in Egypt before the exodus when Israel dwelt there.  I also think it's possible that Mered was a leader in Israel during the later period (e.g. the reign of Solomon) when Israel had a political alliance with Egypt, and the marriage between Mered and Pharaoh's daughter may have been part of that alliance.

Mered must have been a powerful figure to have married a daughter of Pharaoh, but he is comparatively anonymous in the bible.  Because the bible is not a story about the rich and powerful, people like Mered are largely ignored.  He must have been important in his time, but the bible is a religious history and it does not respect wealth or power when choosing its subjects.

The genealogy of Judah concludes with the sons of Shelah, ending the chiasm that encompasses all the sons of Judah.  I talked about this chiasm in the previous two chapters.

I am amused by the phrase in v. 22 where it says "these records are from ancient times".  It amuses me that even in the time when Chronicles was written  (~400 BCE) the author was quoting from records that are "ancient" to him.  It also proves what I had previously asserted, that Chronicles is principally quoting from earlier sources.

For the genealogy of Simeon, v. 33 likely indicates a break between two distinct genealogical records with the phrase "and they kept a genealogical record".

I'm not sure why Simeon is listed second.  Generally, the tribes mentioned most prominently in the genealogy and the ones that are most important in the time that Chronicles was written.  From their history we knew that Simeon's tribal inheritance was in the midst of Judah, and Simeon as a tribe was gradually absorbed into Judah over the centuries.

Verses 41-43 however shows that Simeon as a tribe was still active, expanding and militarily engaged with their enemies during the time of Hezekiah.  It's possible this is why they were included in the genealogy in such a prominent location.  It's particularly noteworthy that the people of Judah were still fighting the Amalekites hundreds of years after the Exodus when their first recorded battle occurred.

Monday, January 18, 2016

Bible Commentary - 1 Chronicles 3

In this chapter, the genealogy continues with the descendants of David and the royal line.

This chapter (in addition to other places) is how we know that Chronicles was written after the exile, because verses 17-24 list some of the royal descendants of king Jehoiachin that all would have lived during and after the exile.  In fact, Zerubbabel (mentioned in v. 19) appears in several other books of the bible and he's a central figure in orchestrating Judah's return from the Babylonian exile.  So we know for sure that at least some parts of Chronicles are post-exilic.

We also know that many parts of Chronicles are much older than the exile, since a lot of the genealogical material was probably ancient even at the time that Chronicles was written (which is itself ~2500 years old).  Most of the historical sections are also largely copied (or at least derived) from Samuel and Kings, but then there are parts like v. 17-24 that are clearly post-exilic, which means that Chronicles must have been compiled, or at least finalized, in the post-exilic timeframe.

I see this chapter as a rushed overview of Judah's history.  Through the list of kings, we see Judah's history before the exile, in the golden age when David and Solomon reigned, through to the exile when Jehoiakim had "successors" and not sons (v. 16), through to the post-exilic period when Israel only had governors and no longer kings.  Most of these kings form the backbone for the later historical portions, particularly in 2nd Chronicles, so this chapter is almost like a kind of foreshadowing.  Nearly all of these kings were already presented in the book of Kings, so my readers should be at least vaguely familiar with them even if you don't remember which are the good ones or the bad ones.

In this chapter the genealogy shifts to a vertical genealogy, giving a chain of descendants, compared to the rest of the genealogy for Judah that is largely horizontal.  (see 1 Chron 1 and Gen 10 for previous discussion of the two types of genealogies).  Since this vertical genealogy is tightly focused on the descendants of David and the royal line for the southern kingdom Judah, it shows us that this will be an area of emphasis for Chronicles as a whole.

One more minor note I want to put in here is that v. 1 lists "Daniel" as king David's second son.  This man is not mentioned anywhere else in the bible, because 2 Samuel 3:3 says that David's second son was named Kileab.  Neither Daniel son of David (who should be distinguished from the prophet Daniel, a completely different person) nor Kileab are ever discussed anywhere else in the bible, and given the prominence of David's other sons, this largely suggests that Daniel/Kileab might have died in childhood.

Sunday, January 17, 2016

Bible Commentary - 1 Chronicles 2

In this chapter, the genealogy continues with the descendants of Jacob and Judah.

By and large, I don't expect my readers to know or care about most of the people named in this chapter.  I don't expect it because I don't know or care about most of them myself.  For instance, you don't really need to know a whole lot about Jerahmeel, son of Hezron, to understand even the book of Chronicles, much less the bible as a whole.  Rather than focus on the names and people, I'm going to focus on the structure and layout of the genealogy to see which family lines are being emphasized.  I will point out a few individuals that have names that interest me, however.

First of all, the genealogy lists all twelve original sons of Jacob (the original twelve with Joseph and Levi, not the "updated" twelve with Manasseh and Ephraim).  However, out of the twelve it only lists the descendants of Judah.  Although David is relevant to the whole nation of Israel, I think this shows a unique emphasis on Judah and the southern kingdom vs. the northern kingdom, which perfectly fits the southern context of this book.  The northern kingdom had already been destroyed and swept away before Chronicles was written, which means that in addition to the southern context of Chronicles, many of the genealogical records from the north were probably also destroyed, making an extensive northern genealogy impossible to recreate.

Secondly, David was the 8th son of Jesse (1 Samuel 16:10-11), but in v. 15 David is listed as the seventh son.  Although it's hard to say for sure, this discrepancy likely exists because the author of Chronicles wanted David to be the seventh son because seven is the number of completion or fullness.  Since David represents the "completion" of God's authority and kingdom on earth, David could perhaps be thought of as the seventh son.  Even though the firstborn is usually more highly favored, it would have been well-understood from their historical narrative in Samuel that David was not the firstborn, and indeed being the youngest and the weakest and smallest is part of David's kingship story, it's part of God's general plan for honoring the younger over the older (cf. Jacob over Esau, Isaac over Ishmael, Judah over Reuben, Perez over Zerah, etc.)  But changing David from the 8th son to the 7th son is hardly noticeable to most people and it puts slightly more symbolic weight behind him.  This is just speculation on my part, but most commentaries I've read suggest that Samuel and Kings are close to a historical account, while Chronicles is more of an idealized history that subtly reshapes certain figures, particularly David and Solomon, to symbolize their hopes for a Messiah.

Also, when it comes to David's genealogy I think it's interesting that Ruth is not mentioned at all.  Actually, Ruth is not mentioned anywhere in the bible at all except for the book of Ruth and a single reference in Matthew 1.  It's possible this is because Ruth is a woman and most women are omitted from biblical genealogies, but at the same time it's also possible that Ruth is omitted because the book of Ruth may not have been available to the author of Chronicles or it may not have been broadly distributed in this historical epoch.  Given that the author of Chronicles seems to have a copy of nearly every other part of the Deuteronomistic history, and given that there must have been some copies of Ruth for it to have survived into the modern era, I think it's most likely that there were copies of Ruth floating around but the Chronicler did not consider them authoritative scripture or relevant to his intended audience.

On a similar topic, verses 16-17 mention a sister of David named Abigail.  I think it's worth pointing out that this is a different woman than the Abigail from 1 Samuel who David married.

A few other names worth pointing out:

Bezalel constructed many of the furnishings of the original tabernacle made by Moses.  My NIV study bible suggests that the author of Chronicles is trying to draw parallels between Bezalel and Solomon, essentially saying that Solomon constructs the new temple the way that Bezalel built many components of the older tabernacle.  I don't think the connection is all that obvious, and I'm also not sure why it's important, but it does seem plausible to me that this was done on purpose.

Ephrath is another name for Bethlehem, but in v. 19 it is also the name of a wife of Caleb.  As far as I know there is no connection between the name of the town and the person, they just happen to be the same.

In terms of the genealogy structure, this entire chapter forms a chiasm around the three sons of Hezron: Ram, Caleb and Jerahmeel, in that order.  The chiasm (ABCCBA) is centered on v. 33, where the phrase "these were the sons of Jerahmeel" indicates the end of Jerahmeel's first section.  Since it continues talking about the descendants of Jerahmeel, this indicates the second section about Jerahmeel in the aforementioned chiasm.  Caleb's second section begins in v. 42, and the chiasm concludes in chapter 3 with the descendants of David (who is himself a descendant of Ram).  Coincidentally, one of the sons of Jerahmeel is also named Ram, but this is a different person from the Ram son of Hezron.  Because of the way the chiasm is structured, it mentions David both at the beginning of the chiasm (v. 14) and at the very end (chapter 3).  The author of Chronicles focuses a considerable portion of this genealogy on David, which forms the background for the later historical section.

Interestingly, much of the section on David's descendants may not have been a part of the original genealogy.  I say this because of the parallelism between v. 50 and 1 Chron 4:4, where v. 50 begins a section on the descendants of Hur and 4:4 ends that section.  This most likely implies that there was some original genealogy that lists the descendants of Jerahmeel, Caleb and Hur, and the author of Chronicles inserted some other genealogical fragment into chapter 3 relating to the descendants of David.  I think this is interesting because it shows how the Chronicler is shaping the genealogy to suit his purposes.

Lastly, there is another extended chiasm around Shelah, Perez and Hezron that extends from 2:3 through 4:23.  It begins by mentioning these three men (Shelah and Perez are brothers, Hezron is a son of Perez) in verses 3-9.  Then the entire section from 2:9 through 3:24 is entirely dedicated to the descendants of Hezron (which itself contains the previously mentioned chiasm around Ram, Caleb and Jerahmeel).  Right when you think the Chronicler forgot about Shelah and Perez, chapter 4 begins with a section on the descendants of Perez and concludes in 4:21-23 with some of the sons of Shelah.

In terms of the overall framing of these chiasms, the outer chiasm of Shelah, Perez and Hezron is designed to give us an overview of the descendants of Judah, while the inner chiasm (the sons of Hezron) is important for framing the genealogy of king David, who is central to the later historical portion in Chronicles.

The most striking omission from this overall structure is Zerah, the last remaining son of Judah.  Even though the descendants of Zerah are mentioned in v. 6-8, Zerah is not part of any of these chiasms, and I'm not entirely sure why.  I don't think Zerah is important to Chronicles, but neither is Shelah so I don't know why Shelah is part of the chiasm and Zerah is not.

In conclusion, even though I discussed some of the individual names, I think the most important thing to look at is the overall structure of the genealogy, and from that we can learn what is the purpose of the genealogy and how it fits into the larger structure and themes of Chronicles as a whole.

Sunday, November 22, 2015

Bible Commentary - 1 Chronicles 1

In this chapter, we find the genealogy from Adam to Abraham's descendants through Esau.

This chapter opens the longest genealogy in the bible at the very beginning: with the creation of Adam.  Right away we can deduce that the author of Chronicles was familiar with the book of Genesis.  While it might seem self-evident (since Genesis is so widely available today), I actually think this is not something we should take for granted.  Especially when you consider how later chapters in this genealogy will refer to figures from Exodus, Numbers, Joshua, Samuel and Kings, it's clear that not only was the author of Chronicles familiar with all of these books, but even more importantly these books already formed a recognized scriptural basis for the post-exilic Jews at the time Chronicles was written (c. 500 BCE).

Chronicles begins with Adam for various possible reasons, but the most important reason is that it establishes Chronicles as a "comprehensive" book.  It echoes the creation story from Genesis to show that Chronicles is going to tell the whole story from beginning to end.  It's not exactly true, per se, but it definitely sets the tone for the book of Chronicles.  For example, the book of Samuel begins with the story of Hannah and the birth of Samuel, and Samuel concludes when David has secured the kingship over Israel.  The book of Kings begins where Samuel leaves off, with David in his old age about to pass on the kingdom to his son Solomon.  Neither of these stories start at "the beginning"; in fact, they start approximately where the last book left off.  Even Samuel starts at a point logically connected to Ruth and Judges, showing us the transition between the Judges period and the kingdom period.  Judges is the natural follow-up to Joshua, which follows Deuteronomy and Numbers, which follows Exodus and Genesis.

All of these books form a more or less contiguous history of Israel from the creation of Adam through the destruction of Jerusalem during the Babylonian exile.  In fact, bible scholars have a name for this contiguous history: it is commonly referred to as the "deuteronomistic history".  The deuteronomistic history has two fundamental ideas.  The first idea is that Joshua, Judges, Samuel and Kings are interrelated and possibly come from a single author or period of authorship, forming a logically continuous work.  The second idea is that Deuteronomy establishes the moral framework and assumptions underlying the historical work.  In broad terms, this includes things like the dichotomy between blessings and curses depending on Israel's obedience to God (Deut 28).  Therefore we can imagine the deuteronomistic history as the history of Israel modeled in terms of blessings for obedience and curses for disobedience towards God.  I think both of these ideas are credible and supported by the text.  More nuanced details of the deuteronomistic history are beyond the scope of my commentary, but I think these broad ideas are quite helpful to understand when reading the text.

Chronicles shows us in this first chapter that rather than picking up where Kings left off, it's actually going to start all over again from the very beginning, and it's going to tell us the history of Israel all over again, from the beginning of creation through the Babylonian exile.  Indeed, Chronicles ends exactly where the book of Kings concludes, but it starts at the beginning of creation rather than where Samuel leaves off.  When you contrast this with the deuteronomistic history mentioned above, you can quickly see that while Joshua through Kings are roughly sequential, Chronicles is more of a parallel history, covering many of the same events but doing so in a different historical context and with different motivations.  The key to understanding Chronicles is to dissect those motivations and understand what the Chronicler was trying to accomplish with this book.  Some of these motivations are discussed in the introduction to Chronicles (just before this chapter), and we will continue to focus on this topic for the rest of the book.

With all that said, there are a few other things I want to say about the genealogy.  First, while it does not discuss the stories from Genesis, by referring to the names of the people involved it calls our attention to those stories.  The Chronicler is undoubtedly familiar with Genesis, and it's likely that he would have expected his audience to have at least general familiarity with the stories and themes of Genesis.  For instance, by telling us the genealogy of Adam, Noah, "Abram, that is Abraham", his readers would remember the first sin, the fall from grace, the flood and Noah's salvation, and Abram's promise from God whereby his name is changed to Abraham, and so on.  That's why I think of this genealogy as almost like an abbreviated history, because as long as you know the stories related to these names, you will think of all these events when reading the names.

Second, the genealogy in this chapter contains a section modeled after the genealogy in Genesis 10 and 11 which lists the descendants of Noah and then the ancestors of Abraham.  Once again this shows that the author of Chronicles has a deep familiarity with Genesis.  However, this genealogy is actually much more extensive than the one in Genesis, which suggests that the Chronicler may have had access to more thorough genealogical records or historical traditions that have since been lost.  This is a common theme across the genealogy because many times the Chronicler will copy genealogies from previous books, but include sections or names that we do not have recorded anywhere else.

Third, this genealogy is meant to show Israel's place in God's created order.  We see all these different people and nations and kings, and then we see Abraham, Isaac and his son Jacob (referred to by his other name, Israel).

Fourth, this genealogy has a peculiar structure.  What it seems to do is list the "preferred" or chosen son last.  For instance, v. 5-16 tell us the descendants of Japheth and Ham before we get to the children of Shem in v. 17.  Verse 28 begins with the genealogy of Ishmael before discussing the children of Isaac.  Similarly, v. 34-35 gives us the descendants of Esau before the children of Jacob.  This is counterintuitive given that many genealogies do the exact opposite, listing the favored son first in the place of honor.  I don't think we need to read any implications out of this.  In my opinion, the genealogy is structured in this way to set up proper transitions from one generation to the next.  To explain what I mean, my readers should remember that there are essentially two different kinds of genealogies.  There are "broad" genealogies that expand out horizontally, listing all of a persons brothers, their sons, and their sons after that, etc.  Basically just going through an entire family tree from one layer to another.  The second kind of genealogy is "narrow" or "vertical", just listing father and son going down some chain of descent for a person of interest.  The genealogy here in Chronicles is a mixture of both techniques.

The Chronicler clearly has a chain of descent he is interested in: he is interested in the tribes of Israel, Judah, the Levites and priests, and the kings of Judah.  This justifies the "vertical" genealogy, which we see in e.g. v. 1-3, v. 24-27 and elsewhere.  However, for various reasons the Chronicler also expands out horizontally at other places (e.g. v. 5-10).  Therefore I see the genealogy in Chronicles as a series of "horizontal" genealogies connected together by these vertical genealogies, sometimes expanding outwards but always refocusing on the people of interest to the author.  The Chronicler lists the favored son last in order to draw our attention back to the next section of the genealogy, which focuses on the descendants of the chosen son, concluding the previous section and opening the next section, with the chosen son given as a transition between these two sections.

Fifth, the genealogy of the Edomites is surprisingly long, possibly because the Edomites were politically significant in the time that Chronicles was written.

Sixth and lastly, as with every other biblical genealogy, this genealogy is overwhelmingly focused on male descent, even though some women are mentioned by name.  Unfortunately, I don't have time to discuss this topic in the depth it deserves, since this post is already quite long.  Hopefully I will have more time in the future to discuss gender relations in the bible.

Saturday, November 21, 2015

Bible Commentary - 1 Chronicles Introduction

I'm really excited to start Chronicles.  Excited and a little nervous, I suppose.  I'm excited because it's always fun to read a new book, and nervous because Chronicles is almost the exact same book as Kings in nearly every way.  I remember the first time I read Chronicles I would think to myself, "wait, do I really have to read all these stories again?"  The worst part is when you get to the list of kings, and it's just a long sequence of names that you don't really recognize, understand or remember.  It might not be so bad if it weren't for the fact that we just went through a long sequence of names that we don't recognize or remember, and now we have to read another list... of the very same kings.  I remember skimming through this book aggressively and filing it away in my brain as "kinda like Kings except with a lengthy genealogy in the beginning".

But fear not, trusty readers: there are many fascinating details and stories in this book, and with patience we should be able to gain genuine insights into the historical period in which this book was written and what it can speak to us in the present about God's heart and God's ways amongst his people.

I think the best way to look at Chronicles is that it's like Samuel and Kings rebooted.  People do this all the time with popular movies, writing and producing the exact same movie except that it's "modern", like different actors and new special effects and stuff like that.    With Chronicles, it's like the history of Israel taken from the Pentateuch, Samuel and Kings except it's been updated and contextualized for the "modern" generation.  At least, it was modern back in 500 BCE.  It doesn't seem modern or hip or fresh to us now, but it was probably a significant shift at the time.

The similarities between Kings and Chronicles are fairly broad.  Like Kings, Chronicles was originally written as a single work and only split into a 1st and 2nd book hundreds of years later, likely when it was translated by the authors of the Septuagint (Greek OT).  And like Kings, Chronicles was written in a similar timeframe, somewhat after the Jews had started returning to the promised land after they were exiled to Babylon, while Kings was written during the exile or only briefly after.  Lastly, Chronicles has a very similar writing style to Kings, with a thematic structure revolving around the progression of kings, emphasizing the changes in Israel's spiritual climate under one king versus another.  Under the good kings, we see a renewal in Israel's relationship with God, and under bad kings we see its degradation.

Much as I am emphasizing the similarity to the book of Kings (similar writing style, time frame and themes), there are quite a few differences as well.  Perhaps the most obvious difference is that the book of Chronicles focuses almost exclusively on the kings and history of Judah (the southern kingdom), while the book of Kings arguably spends more time on the history of Israel (the northern kingdom) than Judah.  In the book of Kings, we spent multiple chapters reading about Elijah and Elisha.  In the book of Kings, Elijah is mentioned 63 times; in the book of Chronicles, he is mentioned once.  In the book of Kings, Elisha is mentioned roughly 52 times; in the book of Chronicles, he is mentioned exactly zero times.  Both Elijah and Elisha were predominantly sent to Israel, hence when the history of Israel is omitted, these prophets also disappear from Chronicles.

Even when describing the kings of Judah, Chronicles adds quite a bit to some stories, filling in a lot of the gaps and omissions in the book of Kings.  In other parts, many stories are left out, especially as it relates to David and Solomon.  The author of Chronicles leaves out nearly everything about David and Solomon that paint them in a negative light.  For instance, he does not describe: David's sin with Bathsheba and Uriah, the succession crisis when Adonijah tried to steal the kingship, Absalom's rebellion, and Solomon's later idolatry when he marries foreign women.  Since this establishes a clear pattern of trying to make David and Solomon look good (perhaps, look better than they actually were), one would naturally ask why would Chronicles leave these stories out?

It's possible the author of Chronicles is trying to create, or is himself clouded by, a perception of a more idealistic past that the Jews could seek to rebuild.  Since Chronicles is pretty clearly post-exilic, the people of Judah are now returning to their homeland for the first time in a generation and trying to rebuild their nation.  The book of Chronicles is perhaps trying to cast a vision for what the nation should aspire to: a united people serving God under a righteous king.  It's hard to say for sure, though.

Another big difference between this book and Kings is the aforementioned genealogy.  I believe this is the longest and most thorough genealogy in the bible.  While I'm going to discuss the details of this genealogy in the coming chapters, what I want to say now is that Chronicles spends a lot of time and energy trying to establish the continuity of their "present day" at the time it was written and the history of David, Solomon and even the earlier patriarchs like Abraham, Isaac and Jacob.  The genealogy does this directly by showing the lines of inheritance between these respective historical figures into the present day, and Chronicle's deep focus on the temple in Jerusalem and God's covenant with Israel establishes continuity in a more spiritual way.  Through these two topics, Chronicles places the post-exilic Judah as both the biological and spiritual inheritors of the promised land, through natural descent and God's promise.  The temple becomes a rallying point that they can gather around both as an artifact of their previous dominion over the land, as well as a symbol of God's enduring promise that they would possess the land forever.

In a manner of speaking, the book of Chronicles is appealing to the past as a way to bolster their legitimacy and claims on the land into the future.  This is particularly relevant in the post-exilic period because the people may not feel like the land of Judah is "their place" without understanding their historical presence in the area.

In summary, Chronicles is a book written primarily for the people of Judah, focusing on the history of Judah, it describes David and Solomon in idealistic terms to establish a historical "golden age" that they could aspire to rebuild when returning from exile, and it seeks to establish a continuity with the past to both justify and inspire Judah's reoccupation of the promised land and Jerusalem.  In all of these aspects, Chronicles is really a product of its time.