Saturday, May 21, 2016

Bible Commentary - 1 Chronicles 13

In this chapter, David tries to move the ark of the covenant to Jerusalem.

This chapter is almost entirely copied from 2 Samuel 6, so it has a very similar purpose in the text, demonstrating David's devotion to the LORD (and at the same time, showing that king Saul was not concerned with the presence of the LORD).  In Chronicles, this section immediately follows the coronation banquet in chapter 12, which makes it appear as if this was David's first action as king.  Samuel tells the story slightly differently, but I don't think the difference is significant.

In broad terms, the picture I see here is David's exuberance and passion for God causing all the people to celebrate just as hard (v. 8), but the turn of events in v. 9 is striking.  Even though the people are celebrating God and joyful, they are acting ignorantly of God's command in the Law of Moses.  In particular, Numbers 4:15 specifically states that the holy things (including the ark) are not to be touched, but they were supposed to be carried on poles that would be placed on the shoulders of the Levites.  This is how they were carried throughout Israel's entire time wandering in the desert and this was specifically the ministry of the Levites.  In this chapter, David and the Israelites made a critical mistake by placing the ark of the covenant on a new cart, mimicking the behavior of the Philistines (which is not discussed in Chronicles, but we read that story back in 1 Samuel 6:7).

The Philistines acted in ignorance, being unaware of the Law, and the Israelites also acted ignorantly, following the example of the Philistines.  Even though it looks like Uzzah is doing a good thing (helping to keep the ark from falling), the people were acting contrary to God's command.  If the ark had been carried by the poles, then this situation never would have come up.

David's fear of the ark is not entirely misplaced, but it does show that when he and the other Israelites interacted with the symbol of God's presence, they needed to treat it reverently and according to God's stated will.  God's ark, like God's presence, is only dangerous if we approach it contrary to the path that God has made.  This shows even more clearly in God's treatment of Obed-Edom, where this Levite (presumably) treats the ark well, and God blesses his whole household.

God struck down Uzzah to show that he must be respected, but he blessed Obed-Edom to show that he is not cruel.  God is not capricious: he responds to these two men in accordance with how they treat his presence.  David was afraid because he saw the first part (the death of Uzzah), but over time he will come to see the second part (that God desires to bless his people) and will eventually move the ark to Jerusalem.  I think there are many people in the world who see God as the killer of Uzzah.  They see a judgmental God that is just waiting for us to mess up and then destroy us when we make the smallest mistake.  They don't see the God who blesses Obed-Edom, which is why it's so important that both stories are in the same chapter.  We need to revere God, honor him, and approach his presence the way that he tells us to, but we also need to see that God isn't waiting to destroy us.  He wants us to draw near so that he may bless us.

Even though the ark remains outside of Jerusalem, the blessing of God continues in the next chapter as David defeats the Philistines again.

Wednesday, April 6, 2016

Bible Commentary - 1 Chronicles 12

In this chapter, more men gather to David in Ziklag and Hebron.

The fundamental purpose of this chapter is to show the unified support for David while he lived in two different cities, which exemplify two different periods in David's life: when he is fleeing from Saul and when Saul is dead and David is going to be made king.  Ziklag is symbolic of David's life in exile when he is hiding from Saul, and Hebron is symbolic of the time after Saul's death when David is already reigning over Judah and about to ascend as king over all Israel.

This chapter shows that he is supported by the entire nation in both periods, but with particular emphasis on Benjamin supporting David even against their relative Saul.  This chapter also shows some of the same tribal bias that was observed in the genealogy, with a particular emphasis on Benjamin and Judah as being supporters of David (particularly verses 2-7, 16).  Since the genealogy seemed to indicate that Judah and Benjamin were the majority of the returning exiles in the time that Chronicles was written, it's possible that this chapter is trying to show that both Benjamin and Judah supported David, which would help smooth over any lingering discord between the tribes given that David was in conflict with the house of Saul for years (including after Saul's death).

The final section in verses 23-37 tries to present a unified nation behind David with support from every tribe, and while this is copied directly from 2 Samuel 5, it skips over 2 Samuel 2 when 1) David goes to Hebron because he is primarily supported by Judah and 2) David is almost exclusively backed by Judah, while all the other tribes support Ish-Bosheth, Saul's heir.  It's only after David (and Judah) fight a war against Ish-Bosheth and defeat him in battle that the rest of the tribes come and support David.

In verses 38-40 all the people who gathered to make David king are eating and drinking together.  This is a biblical motif for ratifying a covenant.  We saw this happen with e.g. Israel and God eating a meal together (Exodus 24:11) to ratify the covenant and when Jacob and Laban ate a meat together to secure their agreement (Genesis 31:54).  The concept of a wedding feast may itself be derived from this tradition.  Here, the people are eating a meal with David to secure their covenantal agreement to obey him as lord while he protects and shepherds them.

There are more minor details that I could pick apart, but I don't find any of them very interesting so I think I'll stop here.  We have learned from this chapter that Israel is unified behind David, Judah and Benjamin are best friends forever, and all Israel is filled with joy now that David is king.  Life is good in Israel and we should all feel positive about it.

In the next chapter, David seeks to bring the ark of the covenant back to Jerusalem.

Tuesday, March 29, 2016

Bible Commentary - 1 Chronicles 11

In this chapter, David becomes king and conquers Jerusalem.

As my readers have probably already noticed, this chapter has a lot in common with Samuel, particularly 2 Samuel 5, just as the previous chapter was largely copied out of 1 Samuel 31.  There's a few things I want to say about this before we move on.

Many of my readers may be getting bored of Chronicles at this point wondering, why so much repetition?  I read this story already!  Why can't they get to something new or different?  To try and answer those questions, do you folks remember way back in Genesis 24 when the narrative repeated the servant's story twice?  And do you remember later in Exodus when chapters 25-31 were largely (but not entirely) copied in Exodus 36-39?  At the time, when explaining those chapters, I said that the repetition was probably a literary device that simply held over from the oral tradition that underlies much of the Pentateuch.  However, Chronicles is very different because Chronicles is a completely separate book from Samuel (while the repetition in the Pentateuch is in the same book) and Chronicles does not have an underlying oral tradition, since as it should be clear from 1 Chronicles 9:1, Chronicles is mostly copied from a previous book.  Even though both of these are instances of copying prior stories, they serve fundamentally different purposes which we can discern through the context.

In a nutshell, Genesis and Exodus contain repetition to help speakers memorize the passages, but Samuel and Chronicles contain repetition because the author of Chronicles wanted to make a point.  We can find that point by studying the omissions and additions that made it into Chronicles, and that will be the main focus of my commentary for the remainder of this book.

In this chapter, the biggest difference from the Samuel narrative is that the Chronicler left out 2 Samuel chapters 1-4.  That includes David's retribution against Saul's murderers and (perhaps more significantly) the civil war that followed between David and Ish-Bosheth.  It also avoids the seven years in which David reigned over Judah from Hebron and jumps almost immediately to his unified kingship from Jerusalem.  Because of the copying from 2 Samuel 5:1, it tells us that David was at Hebron, but Chronicles never explains why he is at Hebron.  The main purpose of this narrative gap is to skip over the disunity and resistance to David's kingship, and present David as if he immediately became king with backing from all the people.

This chapter serves two basic purposes.  First, it establishes David's authority over, and unified support from, all the tribes of Israel.  It does this both in verses 1-3 when the people of Israel come to make David king, and it does this also in verses 10-47 which list David's champions.  Importantly, many of those champions come from tribes besides Judah including Benjamin.  Benjamin is particularly relevant because it is Saul's tribe (David's adversary) and because Benjamin was one of the major tribes returning from the exile (as discussed in chapter 9).  The author of Chronicles is trying to minimize the former antagonism between Judah and Benjamin by presenting David as the king of the whole nation and presenting him as having the support of all the tribes, including Benjamin.  I think this is a big deal to the Chronicler because this entire section (verses 11-47) are copied from 2 Samuel 23, which in the book of Samuel is not even part of the main narrative, it is in the appendix along with "miscellaneous stories", as I think they may be called.  Here, the Chronicler has placed this list of men right at the very beginning of David's reign but with a very important preamble in verse 10 that you do not find in the Samuel narrative.  Verse 10 explains the purpose of verses 11-47: it is to establish the list of very mighty men who supported David to make him king, together with all Israel.  Therefore the Chronicler sees this as a natural extension of verses 1-3 when the elders and the people came to make David king.

The second purpose of this chapter is to establish Jerusalem, freshly conquered from the Jebusites, as the future site for the temple to the LORD.  Chronicles spends a considerable amount of space discussing the preparations and construction of the temple.  It is clear (for various reasons) that the Chronicler is deeply interested in the temple, and the conquest of Jerusalem forms the background for that later temple narrative.  From that perspective, these few verses (4-9) are a small but indispensable part of the larger narrative.

If my readers are interested in more information on the names of the people mentioned in the list of heroes, see my commentary on 2 Samuel 23.  Otherwise, I should mention that the lists of names between these two chapters are not exactly identical (1 Chronicles 11 contains several extra names compared to 2 Samuel), but the differences are not notable or well-understood.

The next chapter continues the theme of David's unified support from all the tribes.

Monday, March 28, 2016

Bible Commentary - 1 Chronicles 10

In this chapter, the historical narrative begins with the death of Saul.

This is a relatively short chapter, but it's important because it reveals a lot about the nature of the historical narrative and its connection to the genealogy that we just read.

So.  First off, my readers may notice that this chapter is almost exactly copied from 1 Samuel 31.  This is important for a couple reasons.  First, it shows that the author of Chronicles is familiar with the book of Samuel, since this is almost a word-for-word copy.  Second, the author of Chronicles is skipping over an enormous volume of the story from 1 Samuel 1-30, which includes things like: the birth of Samuel, the selection of Saul as king, Saul's sins, the selection of David as king, and the lengthy conflict between David and Saul.  None of these things are discussed in Chronicles, but because the story begins here with the death of Saul, the author of Chronicles assumes his readers are already familiar with Saul, David and the war against the Philistines.  Since we know that Chronicles was written hundreds of years after these events, it is likely that the book of Samuel must have been relatively widespread in the time of the Chronicler.  At least, it is just as widespread as the Chronicler intended his own book to become.

We see this most clearly in verses 11-12, where the Chronicler tells us how the men of Jabesh-Gilead honor Saul, but without telling us why.  He simply assumes that we know about how Saul delivered Jabesh-Gilead from the Ammonites in 1 Samuel 11.  In 1 Samuel 31, this story would have made complete sense because the deliverance of Jabesh-Gilead happened earlier in the book; in Chronicles, it only makes sense if we have also read 1 Samuel.

Actually, this is the reason why verses 13-14 are included.  These verses do not exist in 1 Samuel, they are only present here, precisely because Chronicles does not have the prior narrative about the life of Saul with which to explain his death.  In 1 Samuel 28, it is very clear that Saul is going to die in battle as punishment for his sin and disobedience against the LORD; no further explanation is required in 1 Samuel 31 when he actually does die.  In Chronicles on the other hand, the story begins with Saul's death, and the Chronicler felt that it was appropriate to give a (highly abbreviated) explanation.  These two verses still assume that the readers know the story from 1 Samuel because they don't bother to explain the situations in which Saul sinned.

Lastly, I'm not sure why the author of Chronicles began his story here.  Interestingly, this is the same point where 1 Samuel and 2 Samuel are divided, but keep in mind that Samuel was a unified book until the time of the Septuagint (~70 BCE), which is actually older than Chronicles.  Samuel was a single book at the time that Chronicles was written, so if anything it's possible that Samuel was divided here because this is where the Chronicles narrative begins.  I think more likely than that, it is just a natural breakpoint in the story because this is the transition from the "evil king" Saul to the good king David.  Given the context of Chronicles, how it was written when Judah was returning from exile, it's probable that the Chronicler is trying to be more hopeful and inspiring to his readers and wishes to not dwell too long on Israel's troubled past and focus more on the glory days of David and Solomon.

In the next chapter, that glory begins in earnest with David crowned king over all Israel.

Sunday, March 27, 2016

Bible Commentary - 1 Chronicles 9

In this chapter, the genealogy concludes with a census of several groups of officials and leaders who are returning to Judah from the Babylonian exile.

This is it, we've finally reached the end of the genealogy.  After nine painstaking chapters, we have finally reached the end.  It's almost over, and we made it; we survived.  You should pat yourself on the back, not everyone can make it through such a long and archaic genealogy.  Once you are done congratulating yourself, let's move on to discuss the contents of this final chapter.

To begin, verse 1 indicates source of the genealogies, records of "the book of the kings of Israel".  Some people think this means the actual book of Kings (which we previously read).  Other people think it refers to a non-extant royal chronicle.  Since this genealogy includes some names that are not mentioned anywhere else in the bible, I think it's more likely that a non-extant source is intended.  Analysis of the material in the genealogy indicates that it likely came from at least two different sources, possibly as many as three or four.  The reason being, we can identify sections of the genealogy that are taken from earlier books (principally Numbers, the early parts from Genesis and maybe Samuel or Kings), and the new sections are likely taken from other books that have since been lost and destroyed.  The other reason we can separate out different sources for this material is the distinction between military and social or religious genealogies.  This was something I discussed at length in chapter 7, so I won't repeat myself here.

Verse 2 mentions people returning to retake their inheritances in the promised land, which clearly shows the post-exilic nature of Chronicles.  This is in contrast to the book of Kings that never mentions anything after the exile, which shows that Kings must have been written before or during the exile.

Note the groups that are returning from exile.  Verse 3 briefly mentions Ephraim and Manasseh, but there is more detailed discussion of Judah, Benjamin, the priests, and Levites.  All of these groups received the longest and most detailed genealogies in the previous section.  This ties together and explains the author's focus: he is very directly focused on the groups that are now present in post-exilic Jerusalem and Judah, which is an important clue to the author's purpose for this genealogy.  Namely, the reason for this genealogy is to connect the returning exiles in this chapter with the earlier history of their nation in chapters 1-8.  This is intended to legitimize their claims on the land and God's promises from the covenant.  In essence, what the Chronicler is trying to say is that God promised this land to Israel, and their people lived here for thousands of years, and now they are coming back to take what is rightfully theirs both by historical association and by divine mandate.  They are returning, perhaps chastened, but pious.

At the same time, we should also pay attention to the numbers.  Chapter 7 gives us a prior census of some of the tribes of Israel.  In that time, the tribes of Israel were composed of tens of thousands of soldiers, which is not even including women, children and the elderly.  Israel was a nation with hundreds of thousands of people.  In this chapter and we see hundreds of people returning, maybe a few thousand total.  Compare the tens of thousands listed pre-exile with the hundreds that come back from the exile.  Note the implied devastation here.  Even though we do not read many scenes of bloodshed in the biblical narrative, it should be clear from just these two passages that Israel was subjected to harsh treatment by the Babylonians.  Even though the men returning are not all Israel, and many perhaps remained in Babylon, we see less than 1% of the nation return.

Secondly, v. 13 tells us that 1760 priests returned from the exile, while v. 6 and 9 tell us that Judah plus Benjamin together only added up to 1646 men.  This means that there were more priests returning than those other two tribes combined.  Why are there so many priests?  Are they returning because of their devotion to God and to the promised land or because they had favored positions as keepers of the temple ordinances?  Certainly the priests would have had authority and many privileges as leaders of the national religion, and that may have been diminished significantly when they were in exile under a foreign power and in particular, under a foreign, polytheistic religious system.

In v. 17-18, we learn that the senior gatekeeper was responsible for the east gate where the king entered and left the temple.  Subsequent tradition (particularly from Ezekiel 44:1-3) dictates the Messiah would enter through the east gate.  Later, during the (Muslim) Ottoman period the gate was walled up entirely and they also built a cemetery in front of the gate.  According to Jewish law, contact with a grave renders a person ceremonially unclean, so this was clearly an attempt to prevent the Messiah from being able to enter through the gate.  Anyway, it's not directly relevant to this chapter but I thought it was interesting.

Finally, this chapter concludes with a genealogy of Saul, which directly leads us into the next chapter, the death of Saul and the beginning of the historical narrative portion of Chronicles.

Monday, February 15, 2016

Bible Commentary - 1 Chronicles 8

In this chapter, we are given another, more extensive genealogy of Benjamin through the line of Saul.

I'm not sure why the genealogy of Benjamin is duplicated rather than moved here.  This genealogy is much longer and more extensive than the genealogy of Benjamin in the previous chapter, and I don't know why the Chronicler wanted both.  I think the purpose of this genealogy is fairly clear: it is very near the beginning of the narrative section (which starts in chapter 10), and since the narrative begins with the death of Saul, it transitions between these two segments very smoothly by concluding with the genealogy of Saul.  1 Chron 9:1 makes it clear that chapter 8 is the end of the "formal" genealogy as the author regards it, even though chapter 9 includes more names and people.  Actually, chapter 9 includes another copy of the genealogy of Saul, showing once again how important it is regarded by the Chronicler.

Benjamin was the last and youngest son of Jacob, which also makes it appropriate that his genealogy be given last.

What's less clear to me is why the Chronicler wanted the shorter and less relevant genealogy of Benjamin in chapter 7.  I think it might just be there because of the structure of the underlying source material.  Like, maybe the original source genealogy had Issachar, Benjamin and perhaps Naphtali and the Chronicler just copied it wholesale without regards to duplicating a given tribe in the formal genealogy of the twelve tribes.

Similar to Issachar, Benjamin and Asher from the previous chapter, this genealogy of Benjamin is also possibly from a military source.  The term "heads of families" occurs several times, i.e. captains, and v. 40 tells us that some of these men are brave warriors who would be capable in battle.

Verses 6-7 refer to an exile of some parts of Benjamin, but without telling us exactly which one.  I'm not sure if this refers to the Assyrian exile when the northern kingdom was destroyed or the Babylonian exile when the southern kingdom was destroyed.  This would actually make a pretty big difference because Benjamin was a tribe on the border between these two kingdoms so it could have swung either way and we have very little textual evidence to indicate what ultimately happened to Benjamin.  In fact, I think the very existence of this genealogy may imply that Benjamin was at least partially associated with the southern kingdom, because otherwise the records would possibly not even exist for the Chronicler to have copied them.  Verse 28 tells us that these chiefs of Benjamin lived in Jerusalem, which strengthens the claim that Benjamin might have been part of the southern kingdom Judah, and also explains how the Chronicler has their genealogical records.

Verse 29 begins what appears to be a separate genealogy from the passage in verses 1-27.  They look separate because as far as I can tell there is no overlap between the names in one list and the names in the other list.  They are both genealogies from Benjamin, though, so they are taken together as one section.  The first genealogy is difficult to place in any particular timeframe because none of these names are referenced anywhere else in the bible, though v. 6-7 suggests these men could be from the exilic period.

On the other hand, v. 29-40 can be clearly dated to the early kingdom because it is a genealogy of Saul and his descendants.  It includes references to some people we know, Ish-bosheth and Mephibosheth, as well as a bunch of Saul's later descendants who (like Mephibosheth) probably remained in Jerusalem.

Anyway, I don't think there's anything terribly significant about this chapter.  I think it's mostly just a setup for the narrative that begins in chapter 10.

Bible Commentary - 1 Chronicles 7

In this chapter, we are given genealogies of the final six tribes.

I want to take a moment to point out that Zebulun and Dan are not given tribal genealogies.  This is possibly because they were wiped out in the Assyrian exile.  I tried counting the genealogical lists in the last couple chapters and there are only eleven distinct tribes described in chapters 2-7.  Twelve is a significant number in Jewish thought, and the discrepancy is made up by listing the half tribes of Manasseh twice (i.e. the eastern half of Manasseh is listed in chapter 5 and the western half is listed here in chapter 7), making a total of twelve.

With that said, it should be pretty clear that the genealogies of these tribes are much abbreviated compared to Levi and Judah.  While the previous chapter had 81 verses for Levi alone, this chapter has 40 verses for six tribes.  The next chapter has additional genealogies for Benjamin, but for the other five tribes this is all they get.  The entire tribe of Naphtali is described with a single verse.  I think this chapter is listing the six tribes for the sake of completeness rather than because of the Chronicler's genuine interest.

We can also distinguish between two different kinds of genealogies in this chapter.  Issachar, Benjamin and Asher are genealogies derived from military censuses.  We know this because they have official counts of "fighting men" as well as the term "heads of families" (NIV) that can also be used to indicate "leader of a company", i.e. a military unit.  Family trees are often co-opted in the bible into a parallel military organization (for instance, see Numbers 1-2), and for that reason genealogies can serve a double purpose as a military census, and vice versa.  From the military terms, it is very likely that these three genealogies are copied from some other military census.  Interestingly, v. 2 refers to these men as "during the reign of David" suggesting that the data may be coming from David's census in 2 Samuel 24.

On the other hand, Manasseh, Ephraim and possibly Naphtali are all derived from non-military sources because e.g. they do not count the number of men in these tribes and do not list any "heads of families" or leaders over these tribes.  I think this is really cool because this is one of the simplest and most obvious examples of how we can distinguish between original sources that are feeding into the Chronicler's genealogy and from this we can tell that the Chronicler is actually patching together a collection of prior sources to write both this genealogy and his subsequent narrative.

Another example of this sort of discrepancy is that the genealogy of Joshua (v. 20-26) contains ten generations between Ephraim and Joshua, while the genealogy of Moses in chapter 6 presents three generations between Levi and Moses.  This is a considerable difference since Ephraim and Levi are contemporaries, and Joshua and Moses are contemporaries as well.  The ten generations between Ephraim and Joshua is plausible, while the three generations between Levi and Moses is very likely syncopated, and the difference between these two parallel genealogies may also signify that they come from different sources.

We can also find differences in the lists of Benjamin's sons.  Verse 6 gives us three sons of Benjamin, 1 Chron 8:1-2 (the next chapter) lists five sons of Benjamin, and Gen 46:21 describes ten sons of Benjamin.  Even the names are different amongst these lists.  While it may be possible to study the names in depth and find some kind of pattern, for our purposes it's sufficient to note that each different arrangement of Benjamin's sons likely indicates a distinct genealogical source, and Chronicles contains two of them (neither of which are taken from Genesis alone).

The genealogy of Manasseh is also unusual because it includes references to several women: Maacah (Makir's sister or wife - v. 15 and 16 give different accounts of Maacah) and the daughters of Zelophehad (the same Zelophehad from Numbers 27).  This is uncommon but not unheard of (for instance, the punchline of the entire book of Ruth is that she is part of David's genealogy).  I'm not really sure that I could explain why this genealogy has so many women, but I do think it plausibly indicates yet another distinct source for the Chronicler's material.  Ephraim and Asher both refer to a handful of woman as well (v. 24, 30, 32).

Although some parts of this genealogy are copied from elsewhere, large sections of this chapter are also unique to the OT.  I don't think this represents original research by the Chronicler, however.  It's much more likely that the Chronicler is copying from some unknown or lost original source.

Having established that there are both military and non-military sources in this chapter, and having established the strong probability that this genealogy is copied from prior sources and not original, there is another significant observation that we can make.  The genealogies and particularly the military censuses of the northern tribes like Issachar and Asher must almost certainly predate the division of the kingdom of Israel in the time of Rehoboam.  The divided kingdom is unlikely to have unified records, especially sensitive military records.  After the division of the kingdom, most of the records of the northern kingdom would have been kept in Samaria and almost certainly would have been destroyed when Samaria was burned by the Assyrians.  Chronicles must be primarily derived from records from Jerusalem, which was the capital of the united kingdom and after the split, the southern kingdom.  Jerusalem was also sacked by the Babylonians, but since the Chronicler is also from Judah he would be far more likely to have access to the royal archives of Judah than the hated Samaritans.

We can even find hints of these differences in the length of the genealogies.  The genealogy of Judah goes all the way through to the Babylonian exile, the genealogy of Simeon (who was a southern tribe) makes reference to Hezekiah (a king who lived well after the division between north and south, 1 Chron 4:41), the genealogy of Levi goes all the way through the Babylonian exile, but every other tribe has a genealogy that goes no further than Saul.  1 Chron 5:17 says that the genealogy of the Gadites was entered "during the reigns of Jotham... and Jeroboam", but it's a sparse genealogy with very little information, in keeping with the conflict between these two nations at the time.

Lastly, as a minor note, verse 21 gives us a sense of the enduring conflict between Israel and the Philistines.  Even in the time of Jacob and Ephraim, two of Ephraim's own sons died while they were attacking Gath to steal livestock.