Showing posts with label Book club - Phantastes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Book club - Phantastes. Show all posts

Monday, July 4, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 25

This is the end, the last chapter.

At last, MacDonald explains that the Fairy Land was meant all along to be a parallel and a metaphor for the real world, as I quote:

Or must I live it all over again, and learn it all over again, in the other forms that belong to the world of men, whose experience yet runs parallel to that of Fairy Land?
And just as that explains the metaphor of Fairy Land, I believe that with this quote MacDonald summarizes much of the story of this bo
ok: "Thus I, who set out to find my Ideal, came back rejoicing that I had lost my Shadow."

Another great quote that draws together more aspects of the book: "I have come through the door of Dismay; and the way back from the world into which that has led me, is through my tomb. Upon that the red sign lies, and I shall find it one day, and be glad."

And the last quote, which I copy here for the sake of repetition, is thus: "What we call evil, is the only and best shape, which, for the person and his condition at the time, could be assumed by the best good. And so, FAREWELL."

With that is the end of the book. There's not much I can write now, as I have written much in all of my past posts about the various chapters in the book. I will edit this post and add additional comments as they come to me. For now, I will need to spend more time pondering the conclusions of this book.

Saturday, July 2, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 24

I feel like I cut off my last post somewhat prematurely. I will add a few brief comments about chapter 23 and then move on to 24.

I feel like the protagonist's death at the very end is symbolic of his prior "pride death" and emergence of humility. In fact, he says to himself that he considered his life of very little account and therefore gladly gave it up to destroy the evil that he saw in that temple. So in that sense his death is fitting, even though it is mournful for the readers.

This is not the first time in the book that the protagonist faced the possibility of death. He was nearly killed by the Alder/Ash tree spirits and was nearly killed again by the giants. He attempted to commit suicide by jumping into the sea from the rocks, but his life was spared by the boat that floated to him.

And there is an interesting parallel when one considers that earlier attempted physical death (through drowning) and how the protagonist later dies to himself and to pride, after being imprisoned. Both of them occurred during severe bouts of depression and both times he was spared.

And then of course there was the time the protagonist "died" as one of the characters of the books he read, Cosmo. In that instance, he died in the act of freeing a woman he loved from the magical enchanted mirror. In that instance as well, one sees the inner struggle between his desire for control of the woman and his love of her (which requires sacrifice to fulfill it). All those other times, his life was spared, but this time it was not.

Chapter 24 continues the story as it must, with the death of the protagonist. It stirs my heart to see the protagonist once again see his Marble Lady, but now only after death. He had not been in her presence the entirety of the book since he departed the Fairy Palace (not withstanding his later vision of her in the old lady's hut).

Maybe, in some way, his death could be what seals his transformation into the knight, the better man, whom the lady loves. Of course, as I had hinted (but not directly spoken) in prior posts, the protagonist never captures the heart of the Marble Lady. In fact, it appears that the gremlins were correct: the Marble Lady was for a better man, for the knight whose armor was polished from its rust by blows from his enemies. And in that sense, perhaps giving up the Marble Lady to this better man was the final sacrifice required of Anodos (the protagonist) to fulfill his transformation. That it was the giving up, not of his own life, but of his ownership (to quote, "I no longer called her MY Marble Lady", emphasis his) of the Marble Lady to fulfill the death of self that was required to find peace. To quote:
The very fact that anything can die, implies the existence of something that cannot die; which must either take to itself another form, as when the seed that is sown dies, and arises again; or, in conscious existence, may, perhaps, continue to lead a purely spiritual life.

And he does find peace, as this chapter firmly and repeatedly states. He finds the peace of stillness and the cease of earthly strife and toil. Here is another passage that I find to be very strongly written. It speaks of the love that remains within his heart for the Marble Lady, and of the sense of closure that he finds in his death.

I knew that the helpers had gone, and that the knight and the lady remained, and spoke low, gentle, tearful words of him who lay beneath the yet wounded sod. I rose into a single large primrose that grew by the edge of the grave, and from the window of its humble, trusting face, looked full in the countenance of the lady. I felt that I could manifest myself in the primrose; that it said a part of what I wanted to say; just as in the old time, I had used to betake myself to a song for the same end. The flower caught her eye. She stooped and plucked it, saying, "Oh, you beautiful creature!" and, lightly kissing it, put it in her bosom. It was the first kiss she had ever given me.
I will quote MacDonald again, because this is truly the culmination of the book. It's the culmination of the rise of humility in the protagonist's heart, and therefore it deserves repeating for the sake of emphasis, as well as the quality of the prose.

The sun was below the horizon; but his rosy beams yet illuminated a feathery cloud, that floated high above the world. I arose, I reached the cloud; and, throwing myself upon it, floated with it in sight of the sinking sun. He sank, and the cloud grew gray; but the grayness touched not my heart. It carried its rose-hue within; for now I could love without needing to be loved again. The moon came gliding up with all the past in her wan face. She changed my couch into a ghostly pallor, and threw all the earth below as to the bottom of a pale sea of dreams. But she could not make me sad. I knew now, that it is by loving, and not by being loved, that one can come nearest the soul of another; yea, that, where two love, it is the loving of each other, and not the being loved by each other, that originates and perfects and assures their blessedness. I knew that love gives to him that loveth, power over any soul beloved, even if that soul know him not, bringing him inwardly close to that spirit; a power that cannot be but for good; for in proportion as selfishness intrudes, the love ceases, and the power which springs therefrom dies. Yet all love will, one day, meet with its return. All true love will, one day, behold its own image in the eyes of the beloved, and be humbly glad. This is possible in the realms of lofty Death. "Ah! my friends," thought I, "how I will tend you, and wait upon you, and haunt you with my love."
I have quoted this passage in prior blog posts (unrelated to this latest Book Club analysis) because of the substantial meaning in this passage. I won't rehash those points. But what I will say is that again, this concludes the protagonist's arc into humility from a position of pride.

Friday, July 1, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 23

In this chapter, the protagonist becomes a squire. This seems very fitting to me, although as a turn of events it is also rather peculiar and perhaps unpredictable. Yet, it is fitting with the new burst of humility. Throughout the entire book, from the very beginning in the protagonist's castle, when he inherited his father's estate, to when he stayed in the Fairy Palace in his own room, to when he was knighted by his father the king, he was always the one being served by others. Of course, he was often in the need of service, but yet he always received it.

So it seems fitting, now that he is seeking humility and the death of self, that he would now for the first time in this writing be the servant of another. It certainly gives the book a very different character now that he takes orders from another, now that he is not serving himself but he has to maintain the interests of his lord above his own. Even the simple act of walking behind the mounted knight denotes a humility and sacrifice that he would choose a dishonored position.

And even then, all he sees is the honor and the strength, courage and love of the knight whom he serves. And this act, of seeing greatness in another, is also a testament to the growing humility in his heart. For it is from a position of humility that one can see the greatness of others.

On another note, in case you're confused as I was, the beggar-girl referenced in this chapter was very briefly mentioned when the protagonist saw a vision of the Marble Lady with this Knight during his stay at the old woman's hut. It was mentioned that the Knight, as he returned, was coming back from being "taken away" by the beggar-girl for some purpose.

I think the story of the butterfly girl is incredibly cool, but I don't see any particular allegory in it. If anyone else has thoughts on some interpretation, I'd be interested to hear it.

And next, when they come upon the temple of trees and the throne. I won't recount all of the details, except for what sticks out to me. First, I again question whether there is an allegory here. I think the answer is probably yes, but not of a very direct sort. For one thing, he mentions the rotten wood of the throne when he tears it. So that signifies decay from within (much like the Alder tree witch). In this case, due to the religiosity of the descriptions, I get a sense that he is making a subtle criticism of somehow decayed or corrupted religion. Again there is a reference to pride with the carved figure on the throne gazing down upon his followers, and there is the priestcraft that conspires to kill innocents as part of their ritual.

The entire premise of the murder is that it is deceitful and while it is performed openly for all to see, the destructive aspects are too far away for people to see. If they were more perceptive (like the protagonist) they would see the fear of the victims and rise up against it.

But whether the author is speaking of Catholicism or Protestantism or Islam or whatever is non-obvious and perhaps in that sense he is not interested in targeting some particular sect at all.

At the very end is the death of the protagonist, which again I simply did not predict as this doesn't seem to follow any sort of "standard storyline" as told by other books. In that sense, this is yet another reason why I love this book because the author seems to have no problem changing directions suddenly and often.

Thursday, June 30, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 22

Yet again, another amazing chapter. They seem to never stop. This time the protagonist, now on his sad pilgrimage, meets himself in a forest. Certainly MacDonald has a point here, and it is not immediately clear to me exactly what it is. Prior to meeting the knight, he feels a burst of pride in his accomplishments, and then he meets a figure of himself, except stronger and fiercer who overcomes his courage. So I sense a couple things here. The obvious: this represents a personal struggle in his own mind and heart.

But what exactly he is struggling against is not entirely clear. At first, I thought it was pride, because that was the emotion he felt right before meeting his shadow traveling in a new form. And yet, the human reaction to pride is not fear and depression like the protagonist subsequently faces. The way pride attacks people is silently and with subtlety. The fact that he feels depressed over this is almost a sign that he is not actually facing pride.

I'm going to quote MacDonald again because this passage just struck me so powerfully when I was reading it now.

I think I must have fallen asleep, and have slept for hours; for I suddenly became aware of existence, in observing that the moon was shining through the hole in the roof. As she rose higher and higher, her light crept down the wall over me, till at last it shone right upon my head. Instantaneously the walls of the tower seemed to vanish away like a mist. I sat beneath a beech, on the edge of a forest, and the open country lay, in the moonlight, for miles and miles around me, spotted with glimmering houses and spires and towers. I thought with myself, "Oh, joy! it was only a dream; the horrible narrow waste is gone, and I wake beneath a beech-tree, perhaps one that loves me, and I can go where I will.

... But as soon as the first faint light of the dawn appeared, instead of shining upon me from the eye of the morning, it stole like a fainting ghost through the little square hole above my head; and the walls came out as the light grew, and the glorious night was swallowed up of the hateful day.
So among other reasons why I love this is the reference to the beech tree. And then there's the way that he talks about the grim depression of the tower of imprisonment, how it is a horrible narrow waste. It is both small, constrained, and empty, barren and void of life or meaning. It strongly reminds me of how I felt about my "desert experience" back in 2007-2008. And yet, at night is when he is given a vision of freedom and his heart soars. The beech tree was his protector against the darkness of a prior assault, the Ash Tree, much like I had ministering angels protect me, and he feels most alive at night, when the angel of the moon rides through the sky, much like the nighttime was my window to experience God and soar in spirit. To this day, those experiences at night with God stand as some of the strongest and most powerful experiences I've ever had, and yet they truly were these brief 15-30 minute windows of life in an otherwise dry and barren experience. Yet they sustained me through the grace of God.

So that's why I love this chapter. And here is another glorious passage that is so rich I feel I must quote it out of reverence, even though I am assuming that my readers have already read the chapter.

About noon, I started as if something foreign to all my senses and all my experience, had suddenly invaded me; yet it was only the voice of a woman singing. My whole frame quivered with joy, surprise, and the sensation of the unforeseen. Like a living soul, like an incarnation of Nature, the song entered my prison-house. Each tone folded its wings, and laid itself, like a caressing bird, upon my heart. It bathed me like a sea; inwrapt me like an odorous vapour; entered my soul like a long draught of clear spring-water; shone upon me like essential sunlight; soothed me like a mother's voice and hand. Yet, as the clearest forest-well tastes sometimes of the bitterness of decayed leaves, so to my weary, prisoned heart, its cheerfulness had a sting of cold, and its tenderness unmanned me with the faintness of long-departed joys. I wept half-bitterly, half-luxuriously; but not long. I dashed away the tears, ashamed of a weakness which I thought I had abandoned. Ere I knew, I had walked to the door, and seated myself with my ears against it, in order to catch every syllable of the revelation from the unseen outer world.

I am simply quoting this because of the glorious richness and quality of the description. Like the song that he describes, this passage itself conveys life. The song itself speaks of pride again, which is what MacDonald was focusing on before. So this appears to have been his point in the conflict-with-self even though it doesn't entirely seem consistent to me. And then the soliloquy at the end confirms that MacDonald is talking about a battle against pride, that he must give up his claim to knighthood to find humility. He felt the need to give up his claim to knighthood to properly walk in the deeds of righteousness, and from thence to achieve manhood. Or as he puts it, one who desires of himself a hero, will be barely a man, but of him who is satisfied to simply do good works, he shall be assured of manhood.

But he rightly points out that in the death of pride it is possible to raise a new, subtler pride that glories in the death of pride, and thus pride is reborn. In truth and in spirit must your pride die, with rejoicing for sure, but not with satisfaction and self-congratulation. As MacDonald says:

Self will come to life even in the slaying of self; but there is ever something deeper and stronger than it, which will emerge at last from the unknown abysses of the soul: will it be as a solemn gloom, burning with eyes? or a clear morning after the rain? or a smiling child, that finds itself nowhere, and everywhere?

Sunday, June 26, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 21

First, the reference to Sir Gawain is a paraphrase from Le Mort D'Arthur, when Sir Gawain is unhorsed in a joust and proceeds to fight on foot.

In the combat, we discover that both of the brothers' fears proved true. They both died in combat, yet victorious. There isn't any way that I can read this and but wish that the brothers had lived. After reading their stories, you feel a passion for the things of their love: the younger, for his father; the older, for his paramour (umm... not in an adulterous sense).

Reading this chapter makes me feel like the protagonist's depression is returning, and I feel it with him. His brothers dead, his shadow returns (after a long absence), the tower now vacant, and his task to return as the sole survivor to share the glorious deeds of his dead brothers.

The joy and sorrow of the people, the joy and sorrow of the king. They lived the lives of true royalty, and at last the protagonist is dubbed a knight in truth, after he had played the part in battle.

After spending time with many people, widely loved and sought after by "everyone who is anyone", I almost feel like the protagonist is getting a bit overstimulated and is seeking solitude when he goes to travel alone to visit the elder brother's paramour. The story continues in chapter 22.

Phantastes - Chapter 20

This chapter is fascinating. For one thing, you see yet another rapid and generally unexplained transition to a whole new section of the book. There are interconnecting lines with prior sections so it is still part of the whole, but so different in character and tone and so steeply transitioned that it is clearly distinct. I hesitate to call it unexplained because the truth is that the book has no *intention* of explaining, and in fact seems to preclude even the notion of asking for an explanation. It simply "is" and any attempt to build a coherent story is besides the point altogether.

For instance, why did the protagonist wish to enter the tower? A modern mind might ask, but this is not a modern story. It is simply to be taken for granted and the adventure that follows shall come.

One of the many reasons I love this chapter is that we begin to see the protagonist take on the identity of a knight, through his brotherhood with the other two figures and through his battle with the giants. Also being the son of a king adds a royalty dimension.

The old lady says that the protagonist will share with them "in present song and in future deeds", so like I was talking about nobleness of mind/deeds in the last chapter, the old lady now confirms that the protagonist will grow into a nobleness of deeds, much like the knight.

Again there is this bittersweetness, that they felt they would be victorious in battle but die in the process, that permeates the entire book. The songs reinforce this theme.

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 19

This chapter is quite interesting. I consider the description of the island to be somewhat mundane (though it is clearly described as being very peaceful and quiet, so it gives me the sense of unchanging stability -timelessness - much like some descriptions of heaven). The woman is certainly a very interesting character. She is described with traits both young and old. The face is unmeasurably old, yet the voice and the eyes are young and pure, and her back is unbent (again, young). Yet her treatment of the protagonist is very motherly, which again emphasizes old over young. This makes me think the woman is meant to be representative of God, who is also very young and old at the same time, as well as very protective and nurturing towards his children.

I don't have much to say about the song of the knight and the ghostly wife. I don't think it relates with the book much (except perhaps thematically, as much of the book contains similar bittersweet strains).

Spinning wheels are reminiscent of the Greek Fates, reinforcing the God theme.

Note that the actions of the woman when she looks at the four doors dictates what the protagonist finds when he wants through them. The first is the door of tears, which is his strife with his brother and then his death, the second is the door of sighs, the third is the door of fear/pain, and the fourth is the door of ....... something indescribable.

The next section, the door of sighs, seems so significant to me. First of all, it still maintains the general pattern of bittersweetness that you find throughout the book. Second, we discover that the evil kobolds in the underground cavern were correct: it turns out that the Marble Lady is for a better man, and the knight is the better man.

The knight draws a juxtaposition of nobleness of thought vs. nobleness of deeds. Obviously this is what the two characters (the singer and the knight) represent in their turn. Yet the protagonist (the singer) sees a dim reflection of himself in the knight, which makes me feel like the singer could somehow, someday grow into the knight. As such, I feel like these two characters are not so much different people as you might view them as two different stages of the same person. Though this isn't how the story turns out, yet as a metaphor it could be. The lady is destined for a better man, but perhaps through dying to oneself he could become that man. It's like what Jesus says in the bible, "For whoever wants to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for me will find it." He has to die to his ambition and desire for the lady, live in love and service to her, and yet (with respect to the metaphor) could then finally earn her as the knight who he would become.

Again, this isn't how the story turns out as it's told, but I feel like this is one of the undercurrents of the story. Naturally, any death that you suffer with the object of attaining the Marble Lady is self-defeating, which is why it is such a strange paradox. You have to genuinely be willing to give her up to attain the goal of sacrifice and love. And that is the man that she deserves, she who is herself a symbol of creative perfection and idealism. To attain that, you need the characteristics of the knight, who represents masculine perfection (you see these represented in the knight's fight against the ash tree and his physical descriptions): strength of will, nobleness of purpose and deeds, a genuine consideration for others, the hardened shell of steel which is strength, yet the softness of flesh underneath which is mercy and love. The knight loves and respects the singer, which is meaningful given his relationship with the Lady.

The part of this story that resonates with me the most is the concept of the singer's sacrifice, that he must freely give up the Marble Lady to this "better man", when the old lady sings her next song which I will quote below because I think it's so powerful:


O light of dead and of dying days!
O Love! in thy glory go,
In a rosy mist and a moony maze,
O'er the pathless peaks of snow.
But what is left for the cold gray soul,
That moans like a wounded dove?
One wine is left in the broken bowl!—
'Tis—TO LOVE, AND LOVE AND LOVE.

Better to sit at the waters' birth, 
Than a sea of waves to win;
To live in the love that floweth forth,
Than the love that cometh in.
Be thy heart a well of love, my child,
Flowing, and free, and sure;
For a cistern of love, though undefiled,
Keeps not the spirit pure.

This asserts, rightly, that it is *loving others* that brings purity to your soul, and not *receiving love*. That one must be a source of love, and not a recipient, to attain to this purity. Receiving love is good and pure in itself, but it must be giving love to others that will maintain who you are. His escape from this scene, the red mark, guides him into the place of self-sacrifice by leading him into the place of greatest difficulty, accepting the love between the Lady and the "better man".

Things start moving quicker in the next story, the door of dismay, so I would understand if some people get lost in the rapid transitions. Firstly, the well-known form: I'm not 100% sure who this is. Perhaps the protagonist's wife? Maybe mother since I don't remember him mentioning being married at all earlier in the story. Either way, it is obviously some very strongly loved female figure in his life who had recently died. He rapidly transitions through 3 scenes where he is following this figure. First he sees her in the streets, then he finds himself in her house, and he goes to see her room again, and then he finds himself in a church at midnight and he follows her to a tomb.

When he reaches it, the lady was no longer moving but was now a marble effigy. This is obviously a double-reference to the Marble Lady and it adds a whole new dimension to what the Marble Lady means. For up until now in the story, the Marble Lady was the marble of a sculptor, representing creation. In the White Hall of Phantasy, the statues were alive and active, this being the manifestation of creativity incarnate: the chaos and harmony of creative thought itself in a manifest form of dance.

And here, there is a new dimension added. It is the marble statue that is sculpted on the coverstone of a tomb. This is the marble of death, of stillness. Having been to the chapel of Duke University, I have seen marble statues like these before so the symbolism is familiar to me. It is also reminiscent of very early in the book when the singer finds the Marble Lady entombed in alabaster. He freed her from this "death-sleep" and brought her to life, yet now he finds this other, dear female figure entombed and he cannot free her for he has no song this time. Instead, it grows darker and he moves on to the chapel above his burial vault.

Then he finds a knight of marble, one of his ancestors. So it is clear that even though he is not living as a knight (embodiment of masculine perfection), yet he is a descendant of knights and this is his heritage.

At the last, he finds that the red mark which guides him is leading him into the burial vault itself. So once again, he must choose death to self, just like I described above and like Jesus says. This is in many ways the summation of everything in this chapter. Death to self, dying to his selfishness (door #1) and his desires (door #2) and finally death itself, is his only path forward.

The old lady's song reinforces the concept of dying, yet through the process of dying finding life. This is a very Christian concept and reminiscent of the afterlife: that passing through death (the night) one finds true life (the morning).

The next song is again very powerful, and it provides a summary of the 3 doors that he had been through; I quote it below.

We weep for gladness, weep for grief;
The tears they are the same;
We sigh for longing, and relief;
The sighs have but one name,

And mingled in the dying strife,
Are moans that are not sad
The pangs of death are throbs of life,
Its sighs are sometimes glad.

The face is very strange and white:
It is Earth's only spot
That feebly flickers back the light
The living seeth not.

What this song speaks of is a redefinition of what the protagonist had experienced in the three doors: that tears are shed in moments of grief, but also joy; that sighs come from sorrow, but also relief; that in the pangs of death, you find the throbs of new life, whether that be life in this age or in the age to come.

For the fourth door, I don't have anything clever to say because it confuses me. I don't really know what this one signifies. I do have some thoughts, but, like the author, I will leave it a mystery to invite the readers to meditation.

And perhaps given the length of this chapter and the length of my response, my reader(s) will forgive the delay in me publishing this post. :)

Sunday, May 1, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 18

I don't have much to say about this chapter. It concludes the weary battle with depression as he brings an end by diving into the waters, only to be lifted out. This is yet another episode in the book of a sudden, seemingly unpredictable change in scenery as he goes from being underground to being in this desolate sea, and then as he is rescued by a boat the scenery changes again to the flow of water like the flow of time, reviewing his past life. And thus the water proves to not be the waters of death ("passing through the river" is a recurring metaphor for death in classical literature) but the waters of time, flowing on and on.

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 17

I love this chapter. First off, I'd say it's pretty clear that this chapter is about depression, about the darkness that fills a soul when darkness fills one's life. The gremlins are the voices of accusing people or thoughts.

I think the core of what happens here is possession of the Marble Lady. At first, what the protagonist says is, "I no longer called her MY Marble Lady" because he was losing hope. The voices of the gremlins pick up on this thread when they mock him, "you shan't have her." She will not belong to him, she will belong to another, better man.

After that, just barely is the protagonist willing to give up his claim on the Marble Lady: "It is well that thou should'st be, of the nobler, bride."

To give up your own claim to the Marble Lady, after such long and fruitless seeking, is certainly a "spark of nobleness" as the author proclaims.

The point of the second song is similar; by trying to greedily take as much as possible from those things that give you life (a violet, lady's gracious eyes, and "the maid" respectively), you end up killing the source of life and deceive yourself as well, while doing wrong.

The meeting with the elderly woman draws on a different theme, illuminating the depression. From this episode, the reader can discover that this whole country of bare rocks, gremlins and darkness is really just the product of the protagonist's depression over the lost Marble Lady. What the old woman says is that the companionship of any "pretty girl" would be enough to break him out of his depression. When she is transfigured into a beautiful woman, she similarly transfigures the landscape to a beautiful countryside, because the countryside itself is a product of the protagonist's mood. That's why he always chooses the lower paths whenever he had a choice, because the darkness within him was seeking to find darkness without.

The protagonist, in his turn, turns down the woman's claim and continues his search for the Marble Lady (not that he expected to find her).

Thursday, April 7, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 16

This episode, in chapter 16, is something that I am still mentally grappling. He nearly brought the Marble Lady to life, and even without that, he made her visible. He was in the presence of his Lady, and how my heart wished that he would finally find her, rescue her, bring her to life. This is the catharsis that both the protagonist and I are looking for.

But it doesn't happen. This introduces the second of the protagonist's depressions.

The main question I'm grappling with is why the protagonist should not touch her, why is it that he should have sung to her? When you consider the Marble Lady to be figurative for the artistic ideal, what would it mean to touch her?

I've spent an hour now thinking about this question, and the closest I have to an answer is this: it presents a dichotomy between force and inspiration. That's all I got.

In terms of the story line, this marks the protagonist's abrupt departure from the Fairy Palace. He does not return, nor will he ever meet the Fairy Queen, which was a bit of an anti-climax to me, but most assuredly does MacDonald make up for it later.

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 15

I'm not going to write much about this chapter, because while I think it adds a lot to the story, it also seems to be fairly self-descriptive.

Furthermore, I think it follows exactly in line with nearly everything that I've written before. The Marble Lady is like a muse, which according to classical mythology really is an embodiment of artistic inspiration. This is no surprise to me because it is clear to me that women (to put it generally) are the main inspiration for most of the things done by men. Why is the Mona Lisa, one of Leonardo's most famous paintings, a simple portrait of a woman?

But that's a much longer and more important subject than I really want to (or am able to) address. What I will say is that it doesn't surprise me at all because I feel the exact same impulses as MacDonald (through his protagonist Anodos) or Leonardo. Beauty itself, whether that be natural beauty or the physical beauty seen in people, is an inspirational force.

To make one simple comment (in case anyone doesn't notice this), Anodos's song is a description of the Marble Lady's physical appearance, rising from her feet up to her forehead and hair. This song is supposed to match her persistent unveiling as the shadow is lifted off of her.

For the consequences of this song, we read on to Chapter 16.

Friday, April 1, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 14

This chapter is delayed because I had to read it twice.

It's interesting to me how the protagonist does not hear any music. A lot of this book seems to be about art (the protagonist is a singer, the Marble Lady is a physical embodiment of sculpting, etc), so of course music is central to the conceptual framework here.

Note that in later chapters, the central hall is referred to as the Hall of Phantasy. In my opinion this hall is like some sort of encapsulation of the creative process, like a manifestation of artistic or creative inspiration.

The protagonist compares the Hall of Phantasy with the marble cave where he found the Marble Lady, and this is indicative of the similarities (though the Hall of Phantasy is mucher larger in scope). In the cave, he thought about Pygmalion and his sculpture, and he himself was inspired to sing a song that awakened the Marble Lady.

In the Hall, the protagonist is struck with wave upon wave of creative inspiration, where it be a drama, an epic tale, a song, beautiful images, etc.

I believe the reason why the protagonist had to surprise the statues is that his discovery of their motion also parallels the process of creative inspiration. That's why they could anticipate him entering their hall and even anticipate him *thinking* of entering their hall, but are caught off-guard when he does it with a sudden thought to enter, because he was essentially inspired and that allowed him to enter into the realm of creative magic. That magic took the marble statues from the stillness and death of mechanical life, of normality (what is the opposite of inspiration if it is not unthinking repetition?) and drew them into a rhythmic dance guided by celestial music that is not heard by human ears (and yet is discerned in the spirit).

Another similarity with the marble cave, is that the protagonist must sing another song to free the Marble Lady from this new tomb; rather than a tomb of alabaster, it is now a tomb of shadow. In the first case, it was like an unborn creation (from the sculpting metaphor, it was an unchiseled block of marble, yet with the perfect shape waiting within to be unleashed). In the second case, it was a stifled or smothered creation, destroyed or hidden by the sin and darkness that came from the heart of the protagonist (who is also the singer == creator). Of course it is the author's shadow who covers and smothers the creative power that comes from his heart. It is the shadow that battles against him finding and reaching his creative ideal and therefore it is his shadow that he must battle to free his Marble Lady. This seems to me like every artist's battle, to overcome the darkness in their life, to be free in their inspiration and to find and create that Marble Lady that we all seek.

Thursday, March 31, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 13

I'm not sure what to say about this chapter. It is yet another story-within-a-story in this book, and as far as I can tell it has no direct or implied connections to the larger story of Anodos's journey through Fairy Land. I suppose one could draw connections between Cosmo and Anodos (indeed, this is somewhat implied when the author states that Anodos "was Cosmo"), principally because Anodos is described as a singer, while Cosmo is described as a poet. They both fall in love with a distant, almost abstract woman, who becomes a figurative muse for both characters. The Princess is described as being "a form more like marble than a living woman".

But in my opinion this connection is very strenuous, because this character arc, falling in love with a distant woman and through sacrifice earning her love, is pretty much repeated by nearly every author who has ever written a book. It's the story of human life, especially when you interpret it figuratively and let the woman represent an abstraction, such as artistic perfection, as is the case with the Marble Lady.

Cosmo's description of the mirror parallels Anodos's description of how "all mirrors are magic mirrors", that you can behold something plain with your eyes, yet if you look at the same thing in a mirror it has a grace and beauty about it.

Other than that, I must regard this as almost a separate story altogether. Perhaps that is how it is meant to be regarded. It is certainly a very creative story, with great character descriptions. There is Cosmo, this poor yet proud philosopher-poet, who one day accidentally discovers his muse, the nameless woman who enters his room and his life without choice.

He, of course, falls in love with her (as every man is wont to do), and what I love about the story is how MacDonald presents the decision between possessiveness (using the mirror as power over the lady, to compel her) vs. sacrifice (destroying it, which ultimately costs him his life). I think this is the core of the story, and it's what the mirror is about and Cosmo's sacrifice.

I love how MacDonald describes Cosmo as "falling in love with a shadow", because that's really what it is and that is what so many people do. We fall in love with the impressions and first appearances (and indeed, a shadow is just the impression that our body casts on the ground by blocking out some light). We, humanity, have such a strong tendency to falling in love with the very tiny fraction of a person we get to know, like their appearance or their taste in movies, without ever having the opportunity or the ability to fall in love with their substance, the deeper things of the heart.

Yet while most people will not make any sacrifices for a shadow (as they love too little), in the end Cosmo proves himself by giving up his life to destroy the mirror, to destroy his power. He gave up his ability to manipulate her and laid down his life to buy her freedom.

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 12

This is probably my favorite chapter of the entire book, but nevertheless I'm going to try to restrain myself from expostulating too long upon it.

First, as a preface, note that this chapter is split between excerpts from the fictional book that the protagonist Anodos is reading and sections written by Anodos in first person.

The opening paragraph is fascinating to me. Essentially what the author (of the fictional book) is writing is that there is an interconnectedness in the world and in the universe at large that is beyond the physical, scientific or natural. While the most concrete example is certainly natural, that the matter of the earth (iron, copper, gold, carbon, etc) is actually the result of ancient fusion and supernovae in various stars, yet the author insists that this is merely an example of some greater principle. He says that there must be more than "a common obedience to an external law", that "the blank" (in the past) and the "misty spendour" (in the future) may reveal even more relations to creation at large (other planets and stars) than science or poetry can tell us.

What these deeper connections might be, he does not say and I cannot fathom. But he is arguing from an almost inductive stance, that humanity has learned tremendously about the interconnection of life on earth (the so called "web of life"), interconnection to the environment and even to other planets in the solar system (indeed, we would not have tidal forces without the moon), that by induction one can assume these interconnections must continue into the deeper and more exotic places in creations.

I can't agree or disagree, I just think it's an interesting thought, and it's one that is implicitly referenced in the story when the author suggests that children are born in our world (the Earth) when people die in this other, unnamed world.

I'm also fascinated how the world has seasons that change so much more slowly. It seems almost prophetic in the story to think about a woman who might be born in fall or winter and grow up, yet never live to see the spring. How that must burden the heart, to never experience warmth and growth and new life!

I absolutely adore the narrator talking about how he tried to describe sex to the men and women there, how he tried to avoid the topic as much as possible and was eventually forced to describe sex in the "vaguest manner I could invent".

The rest of the story is amazing, but MacDonald tells it better than I do, so I will leave it to him.

Sunday, March 27, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 11

I am fascinated by the description of the pool in the room of stars. I think it's really interesting how there is this pool, it is relatively small and simple (though certainly beautiful), and yet in the reflection of this pool there is "a second deeper sea", the reflection of the stars and the blue painted ceiling. And even more mysterious, when the protagonist dives into the water, he discovers that he is in a third, even larger and deeper sea with rocks and weeds and other inhabitants. It reminds me of C.S. Lewis's description of Narnia in The Last Battle, where Narnia gets larger and larger the deeper in you go.

The biggest part of this chapter though is his discovery of the library, which fills much of the next couple chapters. If discovering the Fairy Palace is the apex of the story, then the books in this library are the heart and soul. Reading these chapters had an effect on me that I could not describe or reproduce with words. Thoughts and emotions alone suffice, yet those cannot be shared in our world here. At least not easily. "... to bathe, with an airy invigorating bath, the limbs which the glow of the burning spirit within had withered no less than the glow of the blazing sun without."

Reading books and experiencing what is described... that makes me think of modern entertainment technology. Movies, and now 3D movies, and Imax, and all of these interactive technologies seem to be trying to recreate what MacDonald has described 150 years ago, a genuinely and deeply interactive experience. It must strike some chord in the human heart that society would spend billions of dollars trying to achieve this.

Saturday, March 26, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 10

Well this one is greatly delayed due to real life stuff. I ended up quitting my job and taking on a new job at a great company, and while I'm happy with the transition it didn't leave me a lot of free time or energy for literary analysis.

Fortunately, things are settling down and now I will move on to Chapter 10 of this fantastic book!

This is a long chapter so it's hard for me to speak of it as a single thing. It is a single story, but it has several different phases. The beginning is the desert. MacDonald writes, "The shadow was in my heart as well as at my heels." In my opinion, this is emblematic of both the desert and the shadow. The hopelessness, the barrenness of life itself. I have been through a desert very like it, although I don't remember seeing the gremlins. Mine was a solitary desert.

Then the next phase is when he sees the stream. It is small, but it is not affected by the desert. It is cheerful even though it travels through a barren land, and the place where the stream goes, it brings life. A couple things I see here. First, he emphasizes the sound of the stream, that it bubbles and "sings", which is interesting because the protagonist himself is described as a singer. Singing is much of his identity. Second, the stream reminds me of the stream referenced in Ezekiel 47, where it flows from the throne of God through the Israeli desert and down to the Dead Sea (AKA the Salt Sea). Everywhere that stream goes, it brings life. It turns the salt water into fresh water.

This interplay between the protagonist and the stream continues with, "A gush of joy sprang forth in my heart, and over flowed at my eyes." Thus while the spring shared Anodos's singing, Anodos shares the spring's "gushing". Also remember that it was a spring of water, flowing from Anodos's basin, that led him into Fairy Land in the first place. This is the second time that he is guided by a stream to his destination.

When he awakes, it's like he awakes from the grief of his shadow. He is in Fairy Land "for the first time" and it's like the story resets. He is still seeking the Marble Lady, but all of the joy and sorrow of the prior events is wiped out.

The "torrent eddies of pain have hollowed a great gulf". Again I believe that MacDonald is comparing the river to Anodos, because Anodos himself finds himself entering a place of tranquility, much like the tranquility of the water in that gulf.

The third major phase of this chapter begins when Anodos rides in the boat; he identifies with the river even more, because now he moves along in the timeless flow of the river, losing himself in "the great flow of sky above... unbroken in its infinitude." He is part of the river and the river is part of him.

MacDonald similarly gives away the purpose of the entire book in this chapter, when he says "But how have I wandered into the deeper fairyland of the soul...!" So it's clear that MacDonald thinks of Fairy Land as an analogy or metaphor of soulish life. Of course, this life that we now live is but an analogy or metaphor for the true life, and how I wish I could awake into that life! That I might die in a dream, and awake into the real life, the true life, of communion with God.

The fourth phase begins when Anodos leaves the river and enters the Fairy Palace. The Fairy Palace is definitely one of the loci of this story, a focus point around which other elements revolve. I feel like the story is structured so that half of it is Anodos's journey to the Palace, and the other half is Anodos's departure from the Palace back to "normal" life. In that sense, being in the Palace is the apex of the story (but not the climax - that comes towards the end).

I find it interesting how the stream flows from the fountain into the palace. Again this reminds me of Ezekiel 47 and the river that flows from the throne of God (well, from the threshold of the temple, but in Revelation 22:1 it flows from the throne of God).

I find it very interesting that Anodos is now marked as Sir Anodos. He is both a knight and a singer, where before in this book it was treated as a juxtaposition: the knight OR the singer. Back in Chapter 6, MacDonald writes:
"I am ashamed," he said, "to appear a knight, and in such a guise; but it behoves me to tell you to take warning from me, lest the same evil, in his kind, overtake the singer that has befallen the knight."
Now Anodos is both. As he falls asleep, this long and powerful chapter ends.

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 9

This chapter is an elaboration on the shadow which to which we were introduced in the prior chapter. It explains the baleful effect of the shadow, which appears to be two-fold: first, it brings about death (by killing the flowers on which the shadow lay) and second and similar to the first, it kills the magic of other people or things. You see that when the shadow destroys Anodos's joy in the vista and destroyed the magic of the boy with the kaleidoscope. It reminds me of the effect of the father in the house that Anodos stayed in, where the father disbelieved in Fairy Land and his skepticism and very laugh had the effect of making Anodos doubt in Fairy Land. In this case, though he did not doubt, the shadow has the effect of taking anything he sees and removing from it the power of Fairy Land, leaving only the "commonplace".

The shadow seems to have the power of disenchantment, removing the glory and beauty of life and leaving only the material, the mundane. I can't help but think of it as a subtle jab at scientific naturalism.

I don't have a clear idea what kind of symbol the maiden with the globe is. I believe this character is referenced later in the book so perhaps that will shed some additional light on it.

The last part of the chapter (the village where appearances change when you get close to someone) defies any attempt at my analysis. I think it makes for a cool story though. :)

Sunday, February 27, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 8

I was discussing this book briefly with my mom recently and I want to add a clarifying note here (which I really should have had at the beginning of the series): This set of blog posts is not meant to replace reading the book. In large part, I do not consider such a summarization to be possible, as the true magic of the book is not in the story or in my brief philosophizing about it, but rather in the actual descriptions and actions in the book.

My commentary is supposed to be an addendum to the book, not a replacement. I hope to make the book easier to understand and perhaps also more interesting, maybe spark some brief discussion or new thoughts and perspectives. If I can do just that much, I will be successful.

That said, chapter 8 is a turning point in the book with the introduction of the protagonist's shadow. The shadow will stay with him through much of the rest of the book, and as with much of the rest of the book, it hints that it is an allegory for something in the real world, without shouting such an allegory. It seems that this book almost continually draws forward towards allegory, akin to works like Pilgrim's Progress, but then almost immediately pulls back by filling in a variety of details that do not fit my attempt at systematizing the book.

This chapter is a perfect example of that trend. When reading it, my first thought is, "The shadow is symbolic of personal sin". It fits biblically (for instance, Romans 6-7 discussion of the sinful desires warring against righteous desires), so it seems like it should be obvious.

And yet there are many unaccountable details (to my mind at least): who is the ogre? Why is the shadow coming out of a closet? Why is there a night's sky in that closet? How does it relate to the quote about the darkness of night filling the universe? I do not have answers to these questions, and it makes me suspicious of the allegory that I myself suggest in the shadow. There is a dearth of consistency that makes me hesitate, which I think is perhaps the author's intention (or again, perhaps not).

Nevertheless, I think from reading the rest of the book it is pretty clear what role the shadow plays in the story. The shadow is the darkness that lies within the protagonist's heart, except that it is given a shape and form in Fairy Land. Wherever the author goes, his shadow goes with him and withers the life he finds around him, destroys the magic and leaves nothing worth keeping. It is the very same destroyer spirit that lived within the Ash, which the ogre vaguely references ("...Especially after meeting one in the forest, whom I dare say you have met"). Greed, lust and destruction are all wrapped together in this sinful destroyer spirit that haunts the narrator, Anodos.

Anyway, that's all for this chapter.

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 7

This chapter contains more of the protagonist's musings on the Alder tree, the paradox of beauty and ugliness dwelling in the same being.

I have thought about this as well, and in brief I have come to the following conclusion: physical beauty is a physical manifestation of the grace of God. I believe that every person who lives is endowed with physical beauty by nature and by grace, and that it's only through an active (though not necessarily intentional) destruction of that beauty that someone can approach what I would call physical ugliness. Without going into detail (I am being brief), an example of this sort of thing is eating disorders. What makes this topic difficult for many people to grasp is that "beauty is in the eye of the beholder" has some truth to it, in the following sense: just because I do not find someone physically attractive does not mean that person is ugly (more properly, non-beautiful). So there has to be some concept of external or objective beauty in order for anyone to truly be beautiful, and I believe that everyone at birth is endowed with objective beauty by the grace of God.

To bring this back to the book, that includes people who do not love God and who walk contrary to his ways. It is this deliberately living contrary to God that fosters inner ugliness (and emptiness, much like the hollowed out sepulchral woman) even though one may still have the external beauty as from birth. But just like the Alder woman, over time the inner emptiness will slowly devour her life until even the external beauty is marred and destroyed.

The next encounter in the story clearly seems to be an intentional allegory, with the husband playing the role of an unbeliever (perhaps an atheist, kind but ignorant), and similarly with the son, though the son is described as being somewhat less benevolent and more scornful or disdainful, while the wife and daughter play the role of believers, those who believe they are in Fairy Land.

I hesitate to draw the allegory too strongly, because there is not a whole lot of details expressed here, but this allegory suggested itself to me immediately when I first read the passage. It reminds me of Pilgrim's Progress more than anything else: even though the family is left unnamed, the similarity in how the protagonist reacts to different characters in different ways is strongly reminiscent of Pilgrim's Progress. Upon further consideration, there are many sections of the book where there are similarities to PP, but never so strongly that I felt like Phantastes was being unoriginal.

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Phantastes - Chapter 6

Phew, chapter 6. This book is very dense and it's only just starting to pick up in pace too. Once again, I will not post a synopsis (to save time), but will instead point out bits and pieces I find interesting.

First, the knight says "....lest the same evil... overtake the the singer that has befallen the knight." So I find this interesting because he defines himself as "the knight" and the narrator as "the singer". So here they are clearly typed. I believe these are both metaphorical types, though to be honest I don't have a clear picture of what they stand for. This is something I am still pondering, as these tropes will show up later in the story as well.

Another point I find interesting is how the narrator thinks "remembering how my songs seemed to have called her from the marble, piercing through the pearly shroud of alabaster...why... should not my voice reach her now, through the ebon night that inwraps her"? So it's like these are described as different types of shrouds, one a shroud of alabaster and the other a shroud of ebony. It's possible this was just meant as a literary device, but it seems to also portend some sort of allegory. Again though, I don't know exactly what.

The rest of the chapter is consumed with the Maid of the Alder Tree. Once more, this figure is an obvious allegory and is a sort of parallel to the Ash. While the Ash represents a sort of male vampirism (see my prior post on Chapter 4 for more discussion of Ash), the Alder tree is described as a sort of female vampire (in later chapters she is discussed more, I am melding that discussion into here). Just like the Ash, the Alder is cursed with a hollowness, an emptiness inside that she tries to fill by manipulating others and consuming their love, like the Alder tree tries to consume people's bodies.

They also use different means of entrapment. The Ash tries to manipulate your fear, the Alder tries to manipulate your desire, to steal your desire and devour it. They are different manifestations of the same spirit.